{
  "id": "us-tulsa-pumper",
  "country": "United States",
  "language": "English",
  "buyer": "City of Tulsa, Oklahoma (Finance Department for the Tulsa Fire Department)",
  "project": "Competitive Sealed Proposal CSP 18-601, Pumper Apparatus",
  "year": "2018",
  "files": [
    {
      "file": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-2.pdf",
      "pages": 98,
      "text_layer": true,
      "what_it_is": "Addendum 2 issue (6 Feb 2018): Addendum 2 change table in redline, bidder questions and answers, Addendum 1, then the full CSP with specification, forms, price sheet and contract terms. Superseded by Addendum 3."
    },
    {
      "file": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf",
      "pages": 119,
      "text_layer": true,
      "what_it_is": "Addendum 3 issue (23 Feb 2018), the governing document: Addendum 3 change table in redline, hose-bed photos, a copy of the Addendum 2 changes and Q&A, Addendum 1, then the full CSP with updated specification, thermal camera annex, quantity schedule, price sheet and contract terms."
    }
  ],
  "quality": "Two near-identical reissues; changes are red strikethrough and underline that only show on the rendered page while the text layer merges old and new words (e.g. '20 two 40 gallons', 'five ten year'), line numbers shift between issues, and Addendum 3 inserted a new value without removing the old one.",
  "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
  "items": [
    "Pumper (engine) apparatus on a custom four-door tilt cab chassis: Cummins ISL9 450 hp, Allison EVS 3000, Hale QMAX 1,500 GPM midship pump, 500-gallon poly water tank with two 40-gallon foam cells, Hale SmartFOAM, five seats; three or more now and 14 planned over five years, each with loose equipment and hose."
  ],
  "checks": [
    {
      "n": 1,
      "area": "purchase",
      "check": "What vehicle is being bought, and how many now?",
      "answer": "Pumper (engine) type fire apparatus with affiliated equipment, three or more, with more in later years depending on funding.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 30",
      "quote": "purchase three or more Pumper, or Engine, type fire apparatus with affiliated equipment."
    },
    {
      "n": 2,
      "area": "purchase",
      "check": "Planned quantity over the contract period",
      "answer": "Added by Addendum 3: 3 now, 3 in fall 2018, 3 in fall 2019, 0 in fall 2020, 5 in fall 2021, total 14 in five years.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 116",
      "quote": "Total of 14 in five years"
    },
    {
      "n": 3,
      "area": "purchase",
      "check": "Which standard?",
      "answer": "Current edition of NFPA 1901; bidder must disclose any deviations between NFPA 1901 and the spec or bid.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 35",
      "quote": "in compliance to the current edition of NFPA 1901 Standard for Automotive Fire Apparatus"
    },
    {
      "n": 4,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Chassis and cab type",
      "answer": "Custom fire-service chassis with medium-length four-door tilt cab, five seated positions (four with SCBA brackets), cab 100 in wide plus or minus 2 in; 10-14 in raised roof (p. 50).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 41",
      "quote": "The chassis will be a custom to the fire service medium length four door cab with side opening doors"
    },
    {
      "n": 5,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Engine",
      "answer": "Cummins ISL9: 450 hp at 2100 rpm, 1250 lb-ft at 1400 rpm, governed 2200 rpm, 543 cu in; Jacobs compression brake (p. 49).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 46",
      "quote": "POWER: 450 Hp @ 2100 rpm"
    },
    {
      "n": 6,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Transmission",
      "answer": "Allison EVS 3000 series automatic with two PTO ports (side and top), programmed for five forward speeds, 68 mph top speed. Addendum 2 struck 'PR' from 'EVS 3000PR' (redline on Addendum 3 p. 11).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 49",
      "quote": "The transmission will be an Allison EVS 3000 series automatic"
    },
    {
      "n": 7,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Maximum dimensions",
      "answer": "Wheelbase no greater than 216 in; overall height no greater than 10 ft 4 in; overall length no greater than 33 ft 6 in.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 40",
      "quote": "The apparatus will have a wheelbase no greater than 216"
    },
    {
      "n": 8,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Suspension and axles",
      "answer": "Rear suspension Hendrickson FIREMAAX EX air suspension, no exception. Front: hub-piloted straight axle and suspension by Dana or Meritor (p. 42); rear single-reduction axle for 68 mph (p. 42).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 43",
      "quote": "The rear suspension will be a Hendrickson FIREMAAX®EX"
    },
    {
      "n": 9,
      "area": "chassis",
      "check": "Rear cab seating",
      "answer": "Three forward-facing SCBA seats along the rear wall (Seats Inc. 911 Battalion or equal, SmartDock). Addendum 2 deleted the rear-facing seat, so the cab seats five: driver, officer and three rear.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 55",
      "quote": "of three forward facing SCBA seats located along the rear wall of the cab."
    },
    {
      "n": 10,
      "area": "body",
      "check": "Fire pump",
      "answer": "Hale QMAX single-stage midship pump rated 1,500 GPM; third-party certified (UL or similar) and fitted with a Trident AirPrime primer (both p. 77).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 76",
      "quote": "midship fire pump that will be plumbed and rated for 1,500 GPM."
    },
    {
      "n": 11,
      "area": "body",
      "check": "Water and foam tank sizes",
      "answer": "At least 500 gallons of water plus two 40-gallon foam cells, one Class A and one Class B. Addendum 2 replaced the original 20 gallons (redline on Addendum 3 p. 18; text layer reads '20 two 40'). Tank of 1/2 in Polyprene by Pro Poly or UPF (p. 84).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 85",
      "quote": "two 40 gallons tanks, one for Class A foam concentrate and the other for Class B foam concentrate."
    },
    {
      "n": 12,
      "area": "body",
      "check": "Foam system",
      "answer": "Hale SmartFOAM or equal, version 6.5 per the Q&A, feeding the front bumper line, crosslays, blitz line, both booster reels, deck gun and 4-inch discharge; Hale EZ-Fill refill system (p. 84).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 25",
      "quote": "The SmartFOAM 6.5, or equal, is deisred to obtain the desired flow."
    },
    {
      "n": 13,
      "area": "equipment",
      "check": "Radio",
      "answer": "Motorola APX6500 7/800 mid-power mobile radio with remote control head, Astro digital P25 trunking and AES encryption (continues on p. 92), plus two ROK Brothers multi-function antennas, no exception (p. 92).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 91",
      "quote": "The apparatus will be provided with a Motorola APX6500"
    },
    {
      "n": 14,
      "area": "equipment",
      "check": "Ground ladders and pike poles",
      "answer": "Duo Safety 24 ft two-section extension, 14 ft roof and 10 ft attic ladders; Duo Safety 6, 8 and 10 ft pike poles; a 17 ft Little Giant (Addendum 2 struck the '11-ft' model text).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 96",
      "quote": "One Duo Safety 24-ft two section extension ladder"
    },
    {
      "n": 15,
      "area": "equipment",
      "check": "Other priced loose equipment",
      "answer": "Three 55-gallon drums Phos-Chek WD 881 Class A and one drum Chemguard 3x3 AR-AFFF, ten PowerFlare kits, Bullard NXT thermal camera with chargers, Scott RIT-PAK III with 5500 psi 75-minute cylinder and PAC mounts; four Vulcan lanterns and ten spare Survivor flashlights on p. 98.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 97",
      "quote": "Three 55-gallon drums of Phos-Chek WD 881 class \"A\" foam"
    },
    {
      "n": 16,
      "area": "scope",
      "check": "Is fire hose in the bid?",
      "answer": "Yes. The bid includes fire hose and loose equipment, which may ship ahead of the apparatus. The annex table puts the carried equipment at about 4,381 lb (p. 34).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 31",
      "quote": "The bid includes fire hose and loose equipment that may be shipped directly to the Tulsa Fire Department prior to delivery of the apparatus."
    },
    {
      "n": 17,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Payment terms",
      "answer": "Progress invoices after TFD physical inspection at benchmarks (loose equipment received, cab and chassis drivable, body being mounted); final payment of at least 10% after final acceptance in Tulsa. The Q&A says that without a response to 1.18 only one invoice after acceptance is recognized (p. 21).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 32",
      "quote": "The final payment, which will be no less than 10% of the total purchase price, will be paid following receipt of the apparatus"
    },
    {
      "n": 18,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Delivery time, place and late delivery",
      "answer": "No more than 300 calendar days from purchase order; driven under own power to 1790 Newblock Park Drive, Tulsa, bidder paying drivers, fuel and permits (p. 32). On a performance failure the bidder negotiates a new schedule of no more than 90 days, failing which the City exercises the performance bond. No liquidated damages clause (full-text search).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 33",
      "quote": "will not exceed 300 calendar days from the date of the issued purchase order or contract to construct."
    },
    {
      "n": 19,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Bonds",
      "answer": "Performance bond of 100% of the bid price on issue of the purchase order (term disputed, see contradictions). No bid bond: full-text search of both addenda finds 'bond' only for the performance bond.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 31",
      "quote": "performance bond in the amount of 100% of the bid price."
    },
    {
      "n": 20,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Product liability insurance",
      "answer": "The completed-apparatus manufacturer must document at least $15 million of product liability insurance.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 38",
      "quote": "$15 million dollars of product liability insurance."
    },
    {
      "n": 21,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Price firmness and escalation",
      "answer": "Prices may not rise during the initial one-year term; four optional one-year renewals (p. 117). Any renewal increase is capped by the bidder's chosen CPI-U or fixed percentage, with 90 days' notice, and the choice counts in evaluation. No separate proposal validity period is stated (searched).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 118",
      "quote": "The prices bid for any Goods and/or Services shall not increase during the initial term of the contract."
    },
    {
      "n": 22,
      "area": "commercial",
      "check": "Pricing format requested",
      "answer": "Five-year totals in four formats: direct from dealer/manufacturer, State of Oklahoma cooperative agreement, HGAC, and another cooperative agreement suggested by the bidder (added by Addendum 3).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 116",
      "quote": "For comparative purposes, please provide pricing in the following formats for 5 year totals:"
    },
    {
      "n": 23,
      "area": "warranty",
      "check": "Overall warranty",
      "answer": "At least two years bumper to bumper on the entire apparatus; it starts on the in-service date, no later than 60 days after acceptance (Q&A, p. 21).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "quote": "No less than a two year bumper to bumper warranty for the"
    },
    {
      "n": 24,
      "area": "warranty",
      "check": "Engine warranty",
      "answer": "At least ten years. Addendum 3 changed it from five (redline on p. 2 shows 'five' struck, 'ten' added; Addendum 2 p. 23 still says five).",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 38",
      "quote": "No less than ten year warranty for the engine."
    },
    {
      "n": 25,
      "area": "warranty",
      "check": "Structural and other long warranties",
      "answer": "Ten years corrosion and cracking for cab and fire body; frame, liners and cross-members for the life of the apparatus; five years paint and striping (p. 37). Also on p. 38: transmission 5 years, Hale pump 5 years, stainless plumbing 10 years, multiplex 5 years, roll-up doors lifetime, compartment lighting 10 years.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "quote": "No less than a ten year fire body warranty for corrosion and"
    },
    {
      "n": 26,
      "area": "scope",
      "check": "Inspection trips: number, party size, who pays",
      "answer": "Bidder pays travel and lodging (p. 35) for: one preconstruction meeting covering all three units, three TFD reps for at least two full days; a mid-construction inspection, three reps for at least one day per apparatus; a final inspection, three reps for at least one full day per apparatus.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 36",
      "quote": "This inspection will include three (3) Tulsa Fire Department representatives for no less than one day per apparatus."
    },
    {
      "n": 27,
      "area": "scope",
      "check": "Training",
      "answer": "At delivery, at least three consecutive days of operational training for training officers and company personnel, plus two days of technical maintenance training for emergency vehicle technicians, both in Tulsa.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "quote": "three consecutive days operational training to Training"
    },
    {
      "n": 28,
      "area": "award",
      "check": "Award method",
      "answer": "Point evaluation: bid price divided by awarded points gives cost per point; times total possible points (7,075, p. 109) gives the bid evaluation number; lowest number is the lowest bid meeting specification.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 30",
      "quote": "Bid Price / Total awarded points = Cost per point"
    },
    {
      "n": 29,
      "area": "award",
      "check": "Required response format",
      "answer": "Separate response addressing every paragraph, in chapters mirroring the spec or with a cross-reference, in writing and as PDF on a USB drive (p. 34-35); exceptions on a separate document; claims of compliance without supporting detail or web links score no points.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 31",
      "quote": "The response to the bid needs to be provided separately from the specifications and needs to address each paragraph of the specifications."
    },
    {
      "n": 30,
      "area": "scope",
      "check": "Is a collision avoidance system required?",
      "answer": "No. Addendum 3 deletes line 11.09 (shown struck through in red), and the clause is gone from the Addendum 3 specification. The text layer still contains the struck words.",
      "evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
      "quote": "The vehicle will be provided with collision avoidance detection while turning or backing."
    }
  ],
  "contradictions": [
    {
      "topic": "Medical cabinet model in the in-cab storage cabinet",
      "side_a": "An OTE International model 1915B medical cabinet will be located on the floor inside the storage compartment.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 54",
      "side_b": "A manufacturer provided OTE model 19503F medical cabinet will be located on the floor inside the storage compartment.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 55",
      "why_it_matters": "Addendum 3 changes the cabinet to OTE 1915B (change table p. 2 and line 4.46) but its own full spec still carries the Addendum 2 model 19503F at line 4.63; two different cabinets with different cost and fit.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Performance bond term",
      "side_a": "The performance bond will remain in effect until acceptance of the delivered apparatus.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 31",
      "side_b": "The performance bond will remain in effect through the two year bumper to bumper warranty period.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "why_it_matters": "Holding a 100% bond for two more years after acceptance costs more premium and ties up bonding capacity, per unit, across up to 14 units.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "When the warranty period starts",
      "side_a": "This date, no greater than 60 days from date of acceptance, will represent the date that warranty periods will begin.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "side_b": "Warranty documents will be completed at the time of apparatus acceptance which will represent the beginning of the warranty periods.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 37",
      "why_it_matters": "Up to 60 extra days of warranty exposure. The Q&A (p. 21) answers it: the in-service date, not more than 60 days after acceptance, but both lines remain in the spec.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Transmission retarder",
      "side_a": "An on/off and selection of high/low performance switch will be provided within reach of the driver for the transmission retarder.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 49",
      "side_b": "A transmission retarder is not being requested and any reference to one needs to be dismissed.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 22",
      "why_it_matters": "A retarder is a real cost item; lines 3.99-3.101 still describe one, but the Q&A says only the engine compression brake is wanted, so it should not be priced.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "4-inch discharge termination",
      "side_a": "The 4-inch discharge will be finished with a 4\" NST male fitting.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 80",
      "side_b": "4\" discharge located on the right pump panel finished with a 5\" locking Storz",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 83",
      "why_it_matters": "NST male thread vs a 5-inch locking Storz fitting are different parts; the large-diameter discharge must be specified one way.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Price escalation over the five-year quantity",
      "side_a": "For comparative purposes, please provide pricing in the following formats for 5 year totals:",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 116",
      "side_b": "a change in price will be considered if the following conditions are met:",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 118",
      "why_it_matters": "The price sheet wants fixed five-year totals while the contract terms allow annual CPI-U or fixed-percentage increases at renewal; a bidder asked which applies and the Q&A (p. 26) did not decide. Whether to build escalation into the totals changes the evaluated price.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Tank-to-pump line size",
      "side_a": "A 3\" tank-to-pump line is to include both a ball valve and check",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 78",
      "side_b": "The tank will be provided with a 1-1/2\" tank fill, 1/2\" tank circulating, and 4\" tank-to-pump line.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 85",
      "why_it_matters": "3-inch vs 4-inch sets the valve, check and plumbing size; the tank outlet and pump line may differ by design, so confirm rather than assume.",
      "status": "likely"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Tank fill line size",
      "side_a": "A manually operated pump to tank, or tank fill line, with 2\" plumbing and valve to be provided",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 79",
      "side_b": "The tank will be provided with a 1-1/2\" tank fill",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 85",
      "why_it_matters": "2-inch vs 1-1/2-inch tank fill changes valve and plumbing; small cost, but the pump and tank chapters disagree.",
      "status": "likely"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Award basis",
      "side_a": "The lowest bid meeting specification will be recommended for award.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 30",
      "side_b": "Selection shall be determined to be in the best interest of the City as evaluated by the City of Tulsa.",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 110",
      "why_it_matters": "The spec promises a cost-per-point formula while the CSP boilerplate lists 13 best-interest criteria (points are only one); it changes how hard to push price versus compliance points.",
      "status": "likely"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Q&A strike of line 2.12 vs renumbered spec",
      "side_a": "Remove / Strike 2.12",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 21",
      "side_b": "Mid-construction inspection of the apparatus when the fire",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 36",
      "why_it_matters": "The Q&A struck the old 2.12 (photo evidence or a one-person chassis trip, Addendum 2 p. 21), but in the renumbered Addendum 3 spec 2.12 is the mid-construction inspection for three reps per apparatus. Reading the strike against the new numbers would drop a paid trip.",
      "status": "likely"
    },
    {
      "topic": "Interior cab coating silently dropped",
      "side_a": "the metal surfaces within the interior of the cab will be painted a protective composite material, similar to a polymer bed liner, gray color.",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-2.pdf, p. 39",
      "side_b": "The in cab storage cabinet on the passenger's side will be as",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 53",
      "why_it_matters": "In Addendum 3 line 4.46 now holds the storage cabinet text and the polymer interior coating appears nowhere, yet the Addendum 3 change table does not list its deletion; ask whether the coating is still wanted before leaving its cost out.",
      "status": "likely"
    },
    {
      "topic": "'Ladder' lettering on a pumper",
      "side_a": "the words \"Ladder\" over eight inch tall numerical digits such as \"30.\"",
      "side_a_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 96",
      "side_b": "ENGINE 21",
      "side_b_evidence": "csp-18-601-pumper-apparatus-addendum-3.pdf, p. 96 (quote read from image)",
      "why_it_matters": "The text calls for 'Ladder' lettering while the sample image under it shows 'ENGINE 21'; negligible cost, but it shows ladder-truck text carried into this pumper spec and the lettering must be confirmed.",
      "status": "confirmed"
    }
  ]
}