{
 "id": "canada-nrc-deaerator",
 "country": "Canada",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "National Research Council Canada (NRC), Real Property Planning and Management",
 "project": "Building M-06 Deaerator Replacement, Montreal Road campus, Ottawa - solicitation 20-58139, NRC project 5889",
 "year": "2021",
 "files": [
  {
   "file": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf",
   "pages": 105,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Tender package: tender form, cost breakdown, buy-and-sell notice (mandatory site visit, closing), instructions, Section 00 10 00 General Instructions (drawing list, completion, alternates, hours, manuals), 00 15 45 safety, 01 21 00 cash allowance. Pages 50-91 are scanned images with no text layer (federal Terms of Payment, General Conditions, insurance, contract security boilerplate); pp. 92-105 security checklist."
  },
  {
   "file": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf",
   "pages": 14,
   "text_layer": false,
   "what_it_is": "Issued-for-tender drawings G01, S01-S03, M01-M10 (A1). Only the cover sheet and title blocks extract as text; the specification sheets (M01-M05) and all notes are vector text that must be read visually. Vessel spec is on M03-M04; GA on M08-M10; supports on S01-S03."
  },
  {
   "file": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf",
   "pages": 8,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 1 (29 Mar 2021, bilingual): pp. 1-2 text (dates, KCD basis of design, drawing reissue notice); pp. 3-6 reissued M02/M02F and M04/M04F Rev 2 with clouded changes, vector text with no text layer; pp. 7-8 scanned mandatory site visit sign-in sheets."
  },
  {
   "file": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_2_.pdf",
   "pages": 1,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 2 (8 Apr 2021): closing moved to April 19, 2021 14:00; Groupe Simoneau Inc. accepted as alternate deaerator manufacturer."
  }
 ],
 "quality": "All vessel requirements sit on A1 drawing sheets drawn as vector text with no text layer, the Deaerator Data Sheet and KCD quotation they lean on are missing, and Addendum 1 reissues two of those sheets with clouded changes.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "HPDEA01 - one new vertical tray-type deaerator with integral vent condenser and storage section (661 US gal storage, 105,000 lb/hr outlet), ASME VIII-1 stamped, TSSA registered with Ontario CRN, full vacuum, replacing HPDEA02 through an existing roof hatch",
  "Deaerator internals and accessories by the deaerator manufacturer: 316 SS spray valves, 430 SS trays, SS vent condenser, relief valve with drip pan elbow, vent valve, thermometers and thermowells, gauge glass, bridle piping, vacuum breaker",
  "Spares: 1 heater manway gasket, 1 storage manway gasket, 2 spray valves, 2 trays (added by Addendum 1)",
  "Deaerator support frame by the equipment supplier on four new base plates (S02/S03)"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "n": 1,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "What is being supplied, and which tag?",
   "answer": "One (1) new vertical deaerator, tag HPDEA01, replacing the existing deaerator HPDEA02 in the same location (Building M-06, NRC Montreal Road campus, Ottawa). Tag and location from M03 heading and M08; 'vertical' from M02 Rev 2.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 12 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "NEW DEAERATOR (HPDEA01) LOCATED IN THE SAME LOCATION AS THE EXISTING (HPDEA02)"
  },
  {
   "n": 2,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "What orientation is the new deaerator?",
   "answer": "Vertical. M02 Rev 2 (Addendum 1) item 2a: 'Vertical deaerator and all associated piping and wiring', with M03/M04 as the deaerator requirements. M09/M10 also draw a single vertical vessel.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "a. Vertical deaerator and all associated piping and wiring. See drawing 5889-M03/M04 for new deaerator requirements."
  },
  {
   "n": 3,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What type of deaerator?",
   "answer": "Direct-contact, tray type, with integral vent condensing equipment and a storage section, designed for two-stage operation (spray valves, then tray stack).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "The deaerator shall be a direct contact, tray type with integral vent condensing equipment and separate water storage section."
  },
  {
   "n": 4,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What is the design capacity and flow basis?",
   "answer": "Total outlet 105,000 lb/hr (47,630 kg/hr) at 230 F (110 C). Inlets: feedwater 9,798 lb/hr (4,444 kg/hr) at 60 F; condensate 88,179 lb/hr (39,997 kg/hr) at 170 F; main steam 7,023 lb/hr (3,186 kg/hr); vent 73 lb/hr (33 kg/hr). Guarantee applies over 10% to 100% of design capacity.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Total Outlet 105,000 (47,630) 230 (110)"
  },
  {
   "n": 5,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "What storage capacity is required?",
   "answer": "661 US gal (2,502 L) in the performance table; storage integral to the deaerator and sized for 3 minutes retention at overflow based on design capacity.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "The storage shall be integral to the deaerator and sized for 3 minutes retention at overflow based upon the design capacity"
  },
  {
   "n": 6,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What design pressure and temperature?",
   "answer": "Only minimums are stated: internal design pressure at least 50 psig, design temperature at least 350 F, otherwise 'as specified on the Deaerator Data Sheet' (which is not in the package, see check on missing documents). MAWP must be equal to or greater than the design pressure (M03 4.1).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Internal design pressure shall be a minimum of 50 psig. Design temperature shall be a minimum of 350 °F."
  },
  {
   "n": 7,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Is vacuum design required?",
   "answer": "Yes, full vacuum: nameplates shall indicate that the vessels are designed for full vacuum (M04 6.4, unchanged in Rev 2). A vacuum breaker is also in the accessory list (M02).",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Nameplates shall indicate that the vessels are designed for full vacuum."
  },
  {
   "n": 8,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "What construction code and stamp?",
   "answer": "ASME Section VIII, Division 1 and latest addenda; designed, manufactured, tested and stamped to it. Code-stamped nameplates on both the deaerator and the water storage sections (M04 6.4).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "The deaerator shall be designed, manufactured, tested and stamped in accordance with ASME, Section VIII, Division 1 and latest addenda."
  },
  {
   "n": 9,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "What provincial registration is required?",
   "answer": "TSSA registration and an Ontario CRN for the new deaerator (and all new piping), per M02 Rev 2 item 5. M03 4.1 adds that the deaerator and water storage sections shall be registered with the TSSA and follow O.Reg. 220/01.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "New deaerator and all new piping to be TSSA registered and hold Ontario CRN."
  },
  {
   "n": 10,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What performance must be guaranteed?",
   "answer": "Effluent within 2 F of saturation; O2 at or below 0.005 cc/L (7 ppb) at the outlet per ASME PTC 12.3; free CO2 0 ppm by the APHA method; over 10% to 100% load. Testing per HEI (colorimetric; titration per PTC 12.3 or CHEMetrics Rhodazine D, 0-20 ppb ampules).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Reduction of O2 in effluent to 0.005 cc/liter (7ppb) or less when tested at the outlet of the deaerator in accordance with ASME PTC 12.3"
  },
  {
   "n": 11,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "What corrosion allowance?",
   "answer": "1/8 in on vessel heads and shell; minimum 1/16 in on nozzles, nozzle necks and manway covers; none required for stainless steel components.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "heads and shell shall be fabricated with a 1/8\" corrosion allowance. Nozzles, nozzle necks, and manway covers shall include a minimum of 1/16\""
  },
  {
   "n": 12,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "What material for surfaces wetted by undeaerated water or gases?",
   "answer": "Stainless steel, stainless-lined or stainless-clad; liners and shields not less than 1/8 in (3.2 mm), attached without welding stainless to the carbon steel shell; any stainless parts heat treated with the vessel must be L grade. Pressure parts and supports otherwise per ASME as needed by design conditions (carbon steel shell implied by the liner language, not stated as a grade).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "shall be stainless steel, stainless steel lined or stainless steel clad. Liners and shields shall be not less than 1/8 inch (3.2 mm) thick."
  },
  {
   "n": 13,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "What tray material and construction?",
   "answer": "Type 430 stainless steel, not less than 16 gauge, riveted or stamped, no welding; interchangeable; housed in a stainless enclosure closed on five sides; tray hold-downs. Spray valves are Type 316 SS spring-loaded (5-200% of capacity); vent condenser stainless, internal direct-contact spray type.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Trays shall be riveted or stamped of type 430 stainless steel, not less than 16 gauge. Welding shall not be utilized for tray construction."
  },
  {
   "n": 14,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "What radiography is required?",
   "answer": "Vessel weld seams radiographed to a minimum of RT-3 per ASME VIII Div. 1; longitudinal joints in nozzle necks fully radiographed (M03 5.5.1); all NDE by ASNT-certified personnel and before PWHT; full-penetration pressure welds (M03 5.2).",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Radiographic examination - vessel weld seams shall be radiographed to a minimum of RT-3 as per ASME Section VIII, Div. 1."
  },
  {
   "n": 15,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Is PWHT required?",
   "answer": "Stated only as: PWHT per ASME code, included as recommended by HEI. No further extent is defined. Stainless parts heat treated with the vessel must be L grade (M03 5.3).",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Postweld heat treatment, in accordance with ASME code, shall be included as recommended by HEI."
  },
  {
   "n": 16,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "What nozzle connection types?",
   "answer": "Sizes to HEI velocity criteria. Unless noted on the Data Sheet, 2 in and smaller socket weld, larger than 2 in butt weld; complete-penetration welds through shell and pads; pump suctions extend 3 in into storage with vortex breaker; SS impingement baffles/liners at least 1/4 in on steam, drain and condensate inlets; location tolerance 1/4 in, tilt 1/2 degree.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "connections 2\" and smaller shall be socket weld and connections larger than 2\" shall be butt weld."
  },
  {
   "n": 17,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "What manways?",
   "answer": "Deaerating section: hinged, bolted manway for tray access, minimum 18 in diameter. Storage section: Clark Kennedy Co. elliptical manway assembly. Each manway has 3/4 in (19 mm) grab rungs inside, bolting, and two spare spiral-wound (or manufacturer-specified) gaskets.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "The storage section shell shall be provided with a Clark Kennedy Co. eliptical manway assembly."
  },
  {
   "n": 18,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "How is the vessel supported?",
   "answer": "On 4 pedestal-type supports welded to the shell, matching the existing support plates and bolt pattern; baseplate bolt holes cut at site at installation; baseplates shipped loose as needed to fit through the existing roof hatch.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "The deaerator shall be supported on 4 pedestal type supports, matching the existing support plates and bolt pattern."
  },
  {
   "n": 19,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Who supplies the support frame, and on what pattern?",
   "answer": "S03: the new deaerator support frame is by the equipment supplier, landing on new 1/2 in top and bottom plates with (4) 3/4 in A325 bolts per plate (base plate types 1 and 2). S02: four base plates at 3'-11\" [1194] by 3'-7\" [1092] centres on existing W14x74 / W10x39 steel.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 4 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "NEW DEAERATOR SUPPORT FRAME BY EQUIPMENT SUPPLIER"
  },
  {
   "n": 20,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "What hydrotest and water quality?",
   "answer": "Hydrotest per ASME code; hydrotest water less than 50 ppm chloride. (Rev 2 misnumbers this clause as 5.8.1; text unchanged.)",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Vessels shall be hydrotested in accordance with ASME code. Hydrotest water is to contain less than 50ppm chloride."
  },
  {
   "n": 21,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "What interior preparation and preservation?",
   "answer": "Interior carbon steel of both sections blast cleaned with silica-free steel grit 16-30 mesh before SS internals go in; after hydrotest, dry with clean heated air and coat with a water-soluble rust-preventive; activated alumina desiccant at not less than 3 lb per 100 cu ft (1 kg per 2.1 m3) in each section; openings sealed airtight for shipment.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Blasting shall be with silica free steel grit of 16 to 30 mesh size."
  },
  {
   "n": 22,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "What exterior surface prep and coating?",
   "answer": "Blast clean to SSPC-SP6 and prime with inorganic zinc; leave 2 in (50 mm) unpainted at field-welded seams; machined weld-end preps get consumable rust-preventive. No finish coat is specified.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Exterior surfaces of the deaerating and water storage sections shall be blast cleaned per SSPC-SP6 and prime painted with inorganic zinc."
  },
  {
   "n": 23,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Is insulation shop or field work?",
   "answer": "Field. The deaerator is field-insulated after installation: 1-1/2 in fibreglass to ASTM C612 Type IA and IB (Johns Manville 800 Series Spin-Glass Type 814, 3.0 pcf or equal), aluminium roll jacket 0.016 in with Poly-Kraft barrier. Nameplates sit on 4 in (100 mm) brackets to clear the insulation.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Deaerator to be field-insulated after installation, with fibre glass insulation meeting ASTM C612 Type IA and 1B."
  },
  {
   "n": 24,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "What goes in the manufacturing data book?",
   "answer": "Manufacturer's data reports, material test certificates, NDE records, heat treatment and hydrotest charts, and nameplate rubbings; plus product data, drawings (paper and electronic) and O&M data; six (6) sets of each (M04 Rev 2 item 8f).",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Documentation is to include manufacturer's data reports, material test certificates, nondestructive examination records, heat treatment and hydrotest charts, and nameplate rubbings."
  },
  {
   "n": 25,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "What did Addendum 1 add to the deaerator submittals?",
   "answer": "Changed by Addendum 1 (M04 Rev 2, clouded item 8a): deaerator specifications and shop drawings must be submitted to the NRC Departmental Representative for review and approval before fabrication. Original M04 had no such item.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Contractor shall submit deaerator specifications and shop drawings to the NRC Departmental Representative with reasonable promptness for review and approval prior to deaerator fabrication."
  },
  {
   "n": 26,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "What spares are required?",
   "answer": "Added by Addendum 1 (M02 Rev 2 item 2c): (1) heater manway gasket, (1) storage manway gasket, (2) spare spray valves, (2) spare trays. The original M02 had no spares list.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "- (1) Heater manway gasket - (1) Storage manway gasket - (2) Spare spray valves - (2) Spare trays"
  },
  {
   "n": 27,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Which accessories come from the deaerator manufacturer?",
   "answer": "Relief valve and drip pan elbow; vent valve with drilled gate; thermometers and thermowells where required (thermometers added by Addendum 1); gauge glass; bridle piping with valves; vacuum breaker - all specified and provided by the deaerator manufacturer. Controls devices (inlet valve, transmitters, level switches) are under the R&R Automation cash allowance.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Accessories to be specified and provided by deaerator manufacturer to suit deaerator requirements."
  },
  {
   "n": 28,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "What site access limit governs vessel size?",
   "answer": "The new deaerator goes in through the existing roof hatch, opening 8'-0 3/4\" [2457] by 5'-7 1/2\" [1715] (both REF) on M08. Addenda 1 and 2 repeat that the DA must fit through the roof hatch; baseplates may ship loose for this.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 12 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "INSTALL NEW DEAERATOR THROUGH EXISTING ROOF HATCH"
  },
  {
   "n": 29,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "What weight is given for the new deaerator?",
   "answer": "Estimated 4,200 lb empty (M09). S01 design loads: empty 18.6 kN, operating 44 kN, flooded 75.6 kN.",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 13 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "NEW DEAERATOR (HPDEA01) EST. 4200LB EMPTY"
  },
  {
   "n": 30,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "What is the design based on, and which makes are accepted?",
   "answer": "Contract drawings are based on Kansas City Deaerator (KCD) shop drawing GA108652, proposal 10865R3 (Addendum 1 item 4). Addendum 2 adds Groupe Simoneau Inc. as an acceptable manufacturer. Either way final shop drawings are still reviewed and the unit must meet the requirements and fit the roof hatch.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 1",
   "quote": "based upon shop drawings provided by Kansas City Dearator, Dwg. GA108652 from proposal # 10865R3"
  },
  {
   "n": 31,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "Are the Deaerator Data Sheet and the KCD quotation package in the package?",
   "answer": "No. M03 sends design pressure, temperature and nozzle details to a 'Deaerator Data Sheet', and the tender's drawing list names a 5-page Kansas City Deaerator quotation package (5889-KCD) as a contract document, but neither is among the four issued files. Searched the full text layer of all four PDFs and looked at every drawing sheet, the reissued sheets, the sign-in sheets and the scanned tender pages 50-91.",
   "evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 29",
   "quote": "5889-KCD- Kansas City Deaerator quotation package (5 pages)"
  },
  {
   "n": 32,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "What schedule constraint applies?",
   "answer": "New deaerator operational by September 30, 2021 at the latest (M01 item 9); all work complete within 26 weeks after notice of acceptance (tender 00 10 00 item 3). Existing deaerator must stay in service until the new one is on site and inspected (M02).",
   "evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "New deaerator shall be operational by September 30th, 2021, at the latest."
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "topic": "Normal working hours on site",
   "side_a": "7:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday to Friday (drawing M01, General Conditions item 6). Quote: \"Normal working hours on the NRC property are from 7:00 a.m. until 5:00 p.m., Monday to Friday inclusive\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday to Friday (tender Section 00 10 00, item 12). Quote: \"Normal working hours on the NRC property are from 8:00 a.m. until 4:30 p.m., Monday to Friday inclusive\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 32",
   "why_it_matters": "Installation labour is priced on the working day; M01 item 3 says the NRC specifications govern discrepancies, so the shorter 8:00-4:30 day likely applies and anything else is after-hours with escort cost.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Number of O&M / documentation sets",
   "side_a": "Six (6) sets of each submittal, including O&M data and manufacturing data books (M04 Rev 2 item 8f). Quote: \"Six (6) sets of each of the above shall be provided.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Two bilingual (or two English plus two French) maintenance manuals and one electronic copy (tender 00 10 00 item 48; M01 item 14a says the same). Quote: \"Provide two (2) bilingual copies of maintenance manuals or two (2) English and two (2) French maintenance manuals and one (1) electronic copy\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 41",
   "why_it_matters": "Copy count and bilingual translation of the vendor manuals and data book are a real documentation cost; the bidder has to pick one.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Deadline for proposing an alternate deaerator",
   "side_a": "Alternates by written application not later than seven (7) working days before tender closing (tender 00 10 00 item 5.2). Quote: \"not later than seven (7) working days before tender closing\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 30",
   "side_b": "Shop drawings for an approved-equivalent request 10 days before tender close (drawing M01 item 10). Quote: \"Shop drawings to be submitted 10 days prior to tender close\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "A fabricator that is not KCD or Simoneau can only bid if approved in time. Addendum 1 then fixed the date at April 6, 2021 (with closing April 16), the sign-in sheet in Addendum 1 shows March 26, and Addendum 2 moved closing to April 19 without restating the alternates date. Governing value: April 6, 2021 per Addendum 1 item 1.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Separate or integral storage section",
   "side_a": "Spec describes a 'separate water storage section'; M04 says the deaerator and storage 'vessels' ship as complete units with separate lifting lugs and code-stamped nameplates on each section. Quote: \"integral vent condensing equipment and separate water storage section\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Same sheet's scope says 'integral storage' (and 5.4 'storage shall be integral'); the GA drawings M09/M10 show one vertical vessel. Quote: \"Deaerating feedwater heater with integral storage\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "One code vessel versus two stamped sections (two nameplates, two sets of lifting lugs, two shipping units, possibly two TSSA registrations) changes fabrication, inspection and registration cost.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Spare manway gaskets",
   "side_a": "Manway furnished with bolting and two (2) spare spiral-wound gaskets (M03 5.5.3), read per manway this is four for two manways. Quote: \"Manway shall be furnished complete with bolting and two (2) spare, spiral wound (or manufacturer-specified) gaskets.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Addendum 1 spares list: one heater manway gasket and one storage manway gasket. Quote: \"(1) Heater manway gasket - (1) Storage manway gasket\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_1-bilingual.pdf, p. 3 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Small cost, but the quantity of spare gaskets is unclear: two per manway (four) or one per manway (two).",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Minimum stainless liner thickness",
   "side_a": "Liners and shields not less than 1/8 in (3.2 mm) (M03 5.3). Quote: \"Liners and shields shall be not less than 1/8 inch (3.2 mm) thick.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Impingement baffles and liners not less than 1/4 in (6.4 mm) stainless plate (M03 5.5.8). Quote: \"Baffles and liners shall be constructed of stainless steel plate not less than 1/4 inch (6.4 mm) thick.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 7 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Doubling liner plate thickness raises stainless material and fitting cost; 5.5.8 may be meant only for impingement liners, but the text does not say so.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Completion date",
   "side_a": "Complete all work within 26 weeks after notice of acceptance (tender 00 10 00 item 3). Quote: \"Complete all work within 26 week (s) after receipt of notification of acceptance of tender.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 29",
   "side_b": "New deaerator operational by September 30, 2021 at the latest (drawing M01 item 9). Quote: \"New deaerator shall be operational by September 30th, 2021, at the latest.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 5 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "With closing on April 19, 2021, 26 weeks runs past September 30; the vessel delivery date the fabricator must hit depends on which deadline governs.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Solicitation number on Addendum 2",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2 carries solicitation number 20-58127. Quote: \"Solicitation No./N° de solicitation 20-58127\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "20-58139_-_5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_addendum_2_.pdf, p. 1",
   "side_b": "Tender package and Addendum 1 carry 20-58139. Quote: \"SOLICITATION #: 20-58139\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "20-58139_-_tender_package_english.pdf, p. 1",
   "why_it_matters": "Addendum 2 holds the governing closing date and the Groupe Simoneau acceptance; a mis-numbered addendum can be missed or disputed when acknowledging addenda on the tender form.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Operating weight on S01",
   "side_a": "Dead loads: operating weight 44 kN. Quote: \"OPERATING: 44 kN\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 2 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Seismic calculation: W = 44.5 kN operation weight. Quote: \"W = 44.5kN OPERATION WEIGHT\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "5889_m06_deaerator_replacement_tender_drawing_e.pdf, p. 2 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Minor, but the vessel supplier's support frame and anchorage design load is stated two ways on the same sheet.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  }
 ]
}