{
 "id": "us-fermilab-expansion-tank-hx",
 "country": "United States",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "Fermi Forward Discovery Group, LLC (FFDG), operator of Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (Fermilab), Batavia, Illinois",
 "project": "PIP-II F37 Building LCW expansion tank and shell-and-tube heat exchanger (RFP 371305 per the package label; the number is not printed in any of the five files)",
 "year": "2025",
 "files": [
  {
   "file": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf",
   "pages": 8,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Appendix B: expansion tank specification ED0042582, May 2025 (initial release for review)"
  },
  {
   "file": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf",
   "pages": 9,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Appendix C: shell-and-tube heat exchanger specification ED0042583, May 2025"
  },
  {
   "file": "FFDG General Terms and Conditions for Commercial Products and Commercial Services (01.2025).pdf",
   "pages": 18,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "FFDG general terms and conditions for commercial products and services (01/2025): warranty, inspection, risk of loss, FAR/DEAR flow-downs"
  },
  {
   "file": "PUR-466_Proposal Certifications-.pdf",
   "pages": 11,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "PUR-466 proposal certifications (rev 2, 06/03/2025): export control, Buy American construction-materials form, other representations"
  },
  {
   "file": "SARC_Subcontractor Annual RepsCerts Rev 4.pdf",
   "pages": 6,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Supplier annual representations and certifications (SARC rev 4): business information form"
  }
 ],
 "quality": "Two short Word specs with uncaught slips: design temperature 150 vs 200 °F and height \"By Vendor\" vs 151 in on facing pages, a plate-exchanger gasket clause in a shell-and-tube spec, a malformed duty \"3,600,00 Btu/hr\", broken table-of-contents links, and no quantity, delivery date or price schedule anywhere.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "Expansion tank (ED0042582): one single-shell, free-standing stainless (316) ASME VIII-1 tank, 38 in ID x 48 in straight side, 250 gal working volume, 150 psi / full vacuum, MDMT -20 °F, four legs, for the PIP-II LCW/PCW loop",
  "Heat exchanger (ED0042583): one TEMA AFM Class B shell-and-tube exchanger, 32 in OD, 192 in tubes (recommended), 316 shell side / SA-516-70 tube side / SA-249 TP316 tubes, 150 psig at 200 °F both sides, LCW cooled by pond water (ICW)"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "n": 1,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Expansion tank: what is it and which construction code applies?",
   "answer": "A single-shell expansion tank (the spec defines \"an expansion tank\", singular) built to ASME BPVC Section VIII Division 1.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 4",
   "quote": "The single shell expansion tank for this project shall conform to the standard requirements of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section VIII Division I"
  },
  {
   "n": 2,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Expansion tank design pressure, vacuum rating and MDMT",
   "answer": "150 psi internal and full vacuum; MDMT -20 °F (Section 3.2).",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "150 PSI / Full Vacuum @ 200oF and -20 oF MDMT."
  },
  {
   "n": 3,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Expansion tank design temperature",
   "answer": "Not a single value: Section 3.2 rates the tank at 200 °F, while the Section 2.3 table says -20 °F to 150 °F. The disagreement itself is the answer (see contradictions); the bidder must ask which governs.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6; p. 5",
   "quote": "150 PSI / Full Vacuum @ 200oF | Design Temperature -20 deg F to 150 deg F"
  },
  {
   "n": 4,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Expansion tank size, heads and capacity",
   "answer": "38 in ID with a 48 in straight side; dished top and bottom heads; 250 gallons working volume.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Straight sides 48”H x 38” ID. | Dished Top and Bottom Heads | Capacity – 250 Gallons Working Volume."
  },
  {
   "n": 5,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Expansion tank materials of construction",
   "answer": "SA240 TP316 plate, A312 316/316L pipe, A182 F316 forgings; Section 1.3 says all components are stainless steel.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6; p. 4",
   "quote": "Materials of construction: SA240 TP316 plate, A312 316/316L pipe, A182 F316 Forgings | All components shall utilize stainless steel as the material of construction."
  },
  {
   "n": 6,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Expansion tank interior and exterior finish (no paint)",
   "answer": "Interior passivated and flushed clean; outside finish #2B with all welds ground smooth and discoloration removed. No coating system is specified for the stainless tank.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Tank interior shall be passivated and flushed clean ready for connection. | Outside finish #2B, all welds ground smooth. Remove discoloration."
  },
  {
   "n": 7,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Expansion tank supports",
   "answer": "Free-standing unit on four stainless steel legs with square pads; leg height to be set during detailed design.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6; p. 4",
   "quote": "(4) Stainless Steel Legs with Square Pads (Leg height to be determined during detailed design) | The expansion tank shall be a free-standing unit."
  },
  {
   "n": 8,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Expansion tank lifting lugs and internals",
   "answer": "Two lifting lugs; one internal baffle located above the tank outlet.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "(2) Lifting Lugs | (1) Baffle above located above the tank outlet"
  },
  {
   "n": 9,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Expansion tank top nozzles",
   "answer": "Top: (2) 2 in RF flanged 150# ANSI, (5) 3/8 in FNPT, (2) 3/4 in FNPT, (1) 1/4 in NPT.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "(2) 2” Raised Face Flanged 150# ANSI. | (5) 3/8” FNPT | (2) 3/4” FNPT | (1) ¼” NPT"
  },
  {
   "n": 10,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Expansion tank bottom and side nozzles",
   "answer": "Bottom: (2) 1-1/2 in flanged 150# ANSI. Side: (2) 3/4 in RF flange for level (no pressure class stated), (1) 4 in RF flanged 150# ANSI supplied with blind, gasket and bolting.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "(2) 1-1/2” Flanged 150# ANSI | (2) 3/4” Raised Face Flange – Level | (1) 4” Raised Face Flanged 150# ANSI. With blind, gasket and bolting"
  },
  {
   "n": 11,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "Expansion tank pressure test, ASME approval and nameplate",
   "answer": "Pressure tested at the factory and ASME approved; ASME plate attached at a readily visible location (agreed during approval); vendor stamps the calculated MAWP and identifies the limiting component.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Tank to be pressure tested at the factory, and ASME approved, ASME plate securely attached | stamp tank with calculated MAWP and identify the limiting component."
  },
  {
   "n": 12,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Expansion tank flange and fitting standard",
   "answer": "All flanges raised-face weld neck to ASME/ANSI B16.5; fittings class 3000# minimum; all nozzles plugged or capped.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Flanges to be Raised Face Weld neck. | ASME/ANSI B16.5 | minimum class 3000#. | All nozzles to be plugged or capped."
  },
  {
   "n": 13,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Expansion tank seismic design basis",
   "answer": "Seismic design per ASCE 7-16 for Batavia, Illinois.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Seismic Design per ASCE 7-16 for Batavia Illinois."
  },
  {
   "n": 14,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "Drawing and calculation approval before fabrication (both items)",
   "answer": "Both items: GA drawings, weld map, weld procedures/qualifications and calculations go to Fermilab for review, and no fabrication starts before approval. Final data book: PMI records and MTRs, certified drawings with weld map, approved calculations, hydrotest reports, welder qualifications/WPS; the exchanger list adds a TEMA datasheet.",
   "evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 7; Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 8",
   "quote": "No fabrication may begin until review and approval of drawings/calculations by Fermilab. | final data book | PMI records and MTR’s"
  },
  {
   "n": 15,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Heat exchanger type, TEMA class and National Board registration",
   "answer": "One shell-and-tube heat exchanger (\"a shell and tube heat exchanger\", singular), TEMA type AFM, Class B, to ASME VIII Div 1 and TEMA; ASME plate plus National Board number and registration required.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 4; p. 6",
   "quote": "shell and tube heat exchanger | Exchanger shall be a TEMA Type AFM Class B. | Unit to include ASME national board number and registration."
  },
  {
   "n": 16,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Heat exchanger preferred vendor",
   "answer": "Fermilab names Doyle and Roth as preferred vendor; substitutes only with FNAL approval.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 4",
   "quote": "FNAL’s preferred vendor is Doyle and Roth, substitutions to this are allowed only with FNAL approval."
  },
  {
   "n": 17,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Heat exchanger shell-side design conditions",
   "answer": "Shell side: 150 psig at 200 °F, MDMT -20 °F, corrosion allowance 0.0 in.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Design Temperature: 200°F Design Pressure: 150 psig MDMT: -20°F Corrosion allowance: 0.0”"
  },
  {
   "n": 18,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Heat exchanger tube-side design conditions",
   "answer": "Tube side: 150 psig at 200 °F, MDMT -20 °F, corrosion allowance 0.125 in (0.00 in on tubes).",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Design Temperature: 200°F Design Pressure: 150 psig MDMT: -20°F Corrosion allowance: 0.125” (0.00” on tubes)"
  },
  {
   "n": 19,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Heat exchanger shell-side and tubesheet materials",
   "answer": "Shell side: SA240 TP316 plate, A312 316/316L pipe, A182 F316 forgings. Tubesheet: SA240 TP316 plate.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Shell Side Materials of Construction - SA240 TP316 plate, A312 316/316L pipe, A182 F316 Forgings | Tubesheet Materials of Construction - SA240 TP316 plate"
  },
  {
   "n": 20,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Heat exchanger tube-side materials and tube gauge",
   "answer": "Tube side: SA-516 Gr 70 plate, A53 Type E pipe, A105 forgings; tubes SA-249 TP316 stainless, 18 BWG.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Tube Side Materials of Construction – SA-516 GR 70 plate, A53 Type E Pipe, A105 Forgings, SA-249 TP 316SS | Tubes to be #18 BWG thickness"
  },
  {
   "n": 21,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Heat exchanger thermal duty basis",
   "answer": "Hot side LCW 200,000 lb/hr max, 113 °F in / 95 °F out; cold side ICW (unfiltered pond water) 200,000 lb/hr max, 85 °F in / 103 °F out; pressure drop under 10 psid each side; fouling 0.0005 (LCW) and 0.002 (ICW) ft2-°F-hr/BTU. The heat duty is printed as \"3,600,00 Btu/hr\" (approximate), a malformed number.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 5",
   "quote": "Flow Rate Maximum 200,000 lb/hr 200,000 lb/hr. | Inlet Temperature 113 °F 85 °F | Outlet Temperature 95 °F 103 °F"
  },
  {
   "n": 22,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Heat exchanger size limits and tube layout",
   "answer": "Shell/channel OD 32 in (required); tube length 192 in (recommended, not mandatory); tube pitch 15/16 in rotated triangular; exchanger centerline 6 ft 0-1/2 in above floor.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Tube Length – 192” (recommended) | Shell/Chanell OD – 32” (required) | Tube pitch: 15/16” rotated triangular"
  },
  {
   "n": 23,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Heat exchanger tube-to-tubesheet joint and channel covers",
   "answer": "Tube-to-tubesheet joints double rolled, expanded and seal welded; channel covers hinged.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Tube to tube sheet joint shall be double rolled and expanded and seal welded. | Channel covers to be hinged."
  },
  {
   "n": 24,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Heat exchanger nozzles",
   "answer": "6 in NPS RFWN process connections on shell and tube sides; all nozzles RFWN; nozzle minimum thickness SCH40/40S.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Process connections shall be 6” NPS RFWN on shell and tube sides. | All nozzles to be RFWN. | Minimum Thickness on all nozzles to be SCH40/40S."
  },
  {
   "n": 25,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Heat exchanger saddles",
   "answer": "A36 saddles attached through reinforcing pads, never directly to the vessel; each pad gets a 1/4 in NPT weep hole, pneumatically tested to 15 psig.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Saddle shall be constructed of A36. Saddle may not be attached directly to the vessel and must be attached to a reinforcing pad."
  },
  {
   "n": 26,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "Heat exchanger factory test and shipping condition",
   "answer": "Complete and preassembled, pressure tested at the factory, flushed clean and dried before shipment; all alloy material PMI tested.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "The heat exchanger shall be complete, preassembled, pressure tested at the factory, flushed clean and dried prior to shipment. | All alloy material to be PMI."
  },
  {
   "n": 27,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Heat exchanger coating",
   "answer": "All external carbon steel surfaces except the saddle coated NAL Blue Light (RGB 65,182,230 / #41B6E6); saddle painted Gray 45 (#A7A8AA). No surface preparation standard or film thickness is given.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "All external carbon steel surfaces of the exchanger (except the saddle) to be coated (NAL Blue Light | Saddle shall be painted (Gray 45"
  },
  {
   "n": 28,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Heat exchanger MAWP stamping",
   "answer": "Stamp at calculated MAWP, not design pressure, with the limiting component clearly identified.",
   "evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "Exchanger shall be stamped at calculated MAWP, not design pressure. The limiting component on MAWP shall be clearly identified."
  },
  {
   "n": 29,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Warranty period",
   "answer": "FFDG standard terms: repair or replace defects appearing within 12 months after initial use or 18 months after delivery and acceptance, whichever is earlier, unless the subcontract sets a different period. No item-specific warranty in either spec.",
   "evidence": "FFDG General Terms and Conditions for Commercial Products and Commercial Services (01.2025).pdf, p. 6",
   "quote": "twelve months after initial use by FFDG, or eighteen months after delivery to and acceptance by FFDG, whichever is earlier"
  },
  {
   "n": 30,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Domestic content clause",
   "answer": "FAR 52.225-1 Buy American Act – Supplies is flowed down in the group of clauses that apply regardless of subcontract value (heading on p. 13).",
   "evidence": "FFDG General Terms and Conditions for Commercial Products and Commercial Services (01.2025).pdf, p. 14; p. 13",
   "quote": "FAR 52.225-1 BUY AMERICAN ACT – SUPPLIES (OCT 2022) | THE FOLLOWING CLAUSES APPLY REGARDLESS OF SUBCONTRACT VALUE"
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "topic": "Expansion tank design temperature",
   "side_a": "Section 2.3 table: design temperature -20 °F to 150 °F. Quote: \"Design Temperature -20 deg F to 150 deg F\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 5",
   "side_b": "Section 3.2: 150 psi / full vacuum at 200 °F, MDMT -20 °F. Quote: \"150 PSI / Full Vacuum @ 200oF and -20 oF MDMT.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "why_it_matters": "The design temperature goes into the calculations and the stamp, so the vendor must be told whether to design and stamp for 150 °F or 200 °F.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Expansion tank overall height",
   "side_a": "Section 2.3 table: total height \"By Vendor\". Quote: \"Total Height By Vendor”\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 5",
   "side_b": "Section 3.2: total height 151 in with 24 in outlet height. Quote: \"Total height 151” with 24” outlet height.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "why_it_matters": "Height sets leg length and steel weight; one place fixes 151 in, the other leaves it to the vendor (and leg height is \"to be determined during detailed design\").",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Gasket clause written for a plate heat exchanger",
   "side_a": "Section 3.3: one-piece NBR gaskets cemented into the gasket groove \"in each plate\". Quote: \"securely cemented into the continuous gasket groove in each plate.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 7",
   "side_b": "Section 3.1 (and 1.1): the unit is a TEMA AFM shell-and-tube exchanger; the rest of the spec describes tubes, tubesheet and hinged channel covers and never mentions plates. Quote: \"Exchanger shall be a TEMA Type AFM Class B.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 6",
   "why_it_matters": "The gasket requirement cannot be applied as written, so the gasket type for the channel and cover joints is undefined and must be clarified before pricing.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "ASME code edition for the heat exchanger",
   "side_a": "Section 1.3: ASME Section VIII Division 1 \"(current edition)\". Quote: \"(current edition)\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 4",
   "side_b": "Reference 5.1: the 2020 edition. The companion tank spec by the same author cites the 2021 edition (Appendix B, p. 8). Quote: \"Pressure Vessels, The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2020.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 9",
   "why_it_matters": "The edition fixes the design rules used in the calculations Fermilab must approve; two different editions in one spec must be settled first.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Which building and system the expansion tank serves",
   "side_a": "Title: F37 Building LCW expansion tank. Quote: \"PIP-II F37 Building LCW Expansion Tank\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 1",
   "side_b": "Section 1.1: Utility Plant building, process clean water (PCW) system (and the p. 5 table calls the fluid deionized water). Quote: \"for use in the Utility Plant building for the Proton Improvement Plan II process clean water (PCW) system.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 4",
   "why_it_matters": "Small price effect (delivery point and service labels), but the documents do not say whether F37 and the Utility Plant are the same building.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "LCW nominal temperature differs between the two specs",
   "side_a": "Tank spec: LCW nominal 82 °F. Quote: \"LCW (Low Conductivity Water) with a nominal temperature of 82 °F\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Appendix B - ED0042582_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Expansion_Tank_Specification.pdf, p. 5",
   "side_b": "Exchanger spec: LCW nominal 95 °F (both specs are titled \"PIP-II F37 Building\"). Quote: \"LCW with a nominal temperature of 95 °F\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Appendix C - ED0042583_PIP-II_F37_LCW_Heat_Exchanger_Specification.pdf, p. 5",
   "why_it_matters": "Little direct price effect because both items carry design temperatures above either value, but it shows the two specs were not reconciled and the tank may sit on a different loop.",
   "status": "likely"
  }
 ]
}