{
 "id": "us-lsu-evaporators",
 "country": "United States",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "Louisiana State University Agricultural Center, Office of Facilities Planning (for the Audubon Sugar Institute pilot plant); documents prepared by American Ingenuity LLC",
 "project": "Pilot Plant Evaporators Renovation: new Roberts type triple effect evaporators (Project No. AS-14-01535, Fabrication Specification M-001 Rev F)",
 "year": "2015",
 "files": [
  {"file": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf", "pages": 376, "text_layer": true, "what_it_is": "One compiled bid package: fabrication specification M-001 Rev F (pp. 4-9), drawing set (title sheet p. 11, skid general arrangement p. 12, P&IDs pp. 13-16, evaporator drawings V-1/V-2/V-3 pp. 17-19), PFDs and design details (pp. 20-37), instrument data sheets and vendor brochures (pp. 38-291, many scanned), evaporator data sheets (pp. 292-304), sight glass sheets and tubesheet white paper (pp. 305-336), filter/pump/strainer/trap sheets (pp. 337-357), condenser, separator and skid sheets (pp. 358-365), pump curves (pp. 366-376). Text layer is partial: drawing pages 11 and 13-19 have outlined text (no text layer), and the data-sheet checkbox choices are coloured boxes that only show in the rendered image."}
 ],
 "quality": "376-page compiled package where the vessel drawings have no text layer, data-sheet choices are coloured checkboxes invisible to text extraction, and the spec, data sheets and drawings disagree on supports, flanges, nozzle types and calandria pressures.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "V-1 first effect evaporator (sugar cane juice), Roberts type, vertical, 2'-6\" I.D., with calandria, 1 required",
  "V-2 second effect evaporator, same shell as V-1, 1 required",
  "V-3 third effect evaporator, same shell as V-1, 1 required",
  "T-1, T-2, T-3 steam condensate tanks (spec sheets) and T-4 condensate tank (design detail 11, identical in size): 1'-6\" diameter, 304 SS, full vacuum/14 psig",
  "E-1 third effect vacuum condenser, TEMA BEU shell and tube exchanger, ASME VIII and TEMA C",
  "T-5 vacuum pump gas/liquid separator (Eaton Model TS named), carbon steel, on skid no. 2 with vacuum pump P-5",
  "FL-1 optional area steam filter (Pall cartridge filter housing, 316 SS)",
  "Skid no. 1 (evaporators, tanks, pumps, condenser, piping, valves, instruments, platform, ladder) fully shop assembled; skid no. 2 for P-5 and T-5"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {"n": 1, "area": "scope", "check": "What is being bought", "answer": "Design, manufacture and delivery of a Roberts type triple effect skid-mounted evaporator system (evaporators V-1, V-2, V-3 with calandrias) complete with the accessories in the attached documents, for the Audubon Sugar Institute pilot plant. Installation by others.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 6", "quote": "delivery of a Roberts Type Triple Effect Skid Mounted Evaporator System, complete with all accessories specified in attached documentation."},
  {"n": 2, "area": "scope", "check": "Quantity of each evaporator", "answer": "One each of V-1, V-2 and V-3 (three evaporators). Each data sheet gives total required 1 and each vessel drawing says (1ea) REQ'D.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 293", "quote": "TOTAL NO. REQ'D.: 1"},
  {"n": 3, "area": "code", "check": "Construction code and stamp for the evaporators", "answer": "ASME Section VIII, Division 1, with ASME Code stamp (data sheet: ASME CODE STAMP REQ'D marked YES; calandria sheet option marked 'ASME SECT. VIII, DIV. I CODE AND STAMP'). Drawings: designed and fabricated to the latest edition of ASME VIII Div. 1.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "X ASME SECT. VIII, DIV. I CODE AND STAMP"},
  {"n": 4, "area": "code", "check": "National Board registration", "answer": "Not required. On all three evaporator data sheets (pp. 293, 297, 301) the NATIONAL BOARD REGIST. REQ'D box is marked NO; the separate 'NATIONAL BOARD' box beside the code line is unmarked.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 293", "quote": "NATIONAL BOARD REGIST. REQ'D: [X] NO [ ] YES [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 5, "area": "design", "check": "Evaporator body design pressure, vacuum and temperature", "answer": "50 psig and full vacuum, 350 °F (all three drawings; data sheets give design press. 50 psig, design vac. FULL, design temp. 350 °F).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "quote": "BODY DESIGN PRESSURE =50 psig / FV DESIGN TEMP. =350 °F [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 6, "area": "design", "check": "Calandria design and test pressures as given on the data sheets", "answer": "Calandria sheet (sheet 3 of 4, same on V-1/V-2/V-3): shell side (steam) 50 psig/FV, test 75 psig; tube side (sugar cane juice) 80 psig/FV, test 120 psig; design temperature 350 °F both sides. The drawings instead give CALANDRIA DESIGN PRESSURE = 80 psig (see contradictions).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "DESIGN PRESSURE PSIG 50 PSIG/FV 80 PSIG/FV"},
  {"n": 7, "area": "design", "check": "MDMT", "answer": "20 °F at MAWP, on all three evaporator data sheets.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 293", "quote": "MDMT@ MAWP: 20 DEG F"},
  {"n": 8, "area": "materials", "check": "Evaporator pressure-part material", "answer": "304 stainless steel: shell 304 SS; flanges ASTM A182 304 SS; all nozzles and couplings 304 SS; calandria shell, nozzles and tubesheet SS 304 (drawing). The drawing general note instead calls flanged connections SA-105 (see contradictions).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 293", "quote": "T.L.-T.L.: MAT'L: 304 SS"},
  {"n": 9, "area": "materials", "check": "Calandria tubes and heating surface", "answer": "2-inch 14 gauge 304 SS tubes in a 304 SS tubesheet; 75 sq ft heating surface per calandria; one pass; tube count not given and shell thickness to be supplied by vendor.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "MATERIAL - TUBES: 2\" 14 GAUGE 304 SS/304 SS TUBESHEET"},
  {"n": 10, "area": "materials", "check": "Corrosion allowance", "answer": "Zero. Data sheets give corrosion allowance 0 in.; calandria note 3 says shell and tubes zero corrosion allowance; drawings give 0\" for body and calandria shell.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "SHELL AND TUBES SHALL HAVE ZERO CORROSION ALLOWANCE."},
  {"n": 11, "area": "materials", "check": "Bolting and gaskets", "answer": "Calandria: bolts ASTM A-193 Gr. B7, nuts ASTM A-194 Gr. 2H, gaskets 304 SS/Teflon spiral wound Flexitallic type CGI (sheet 3 and drawings). V-2 and V-3 sheet 1 give external bolts/studs and nuts as 304 SS and gaskets SS304/Teflon spiral wound style CGI; V-1 sheet 1 leaves bolting blank.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "MATERIAL - BOLTS: ASTM A-193 GR. B7 MATERIAL - NUTS: ASTM A-194 GR. 2H"},
  {"n": 12, "area": "nozzles", "check": "Calandria flanges", "answer": "Calandria sheet note 4: specify standard industrial Class 75 flanges rated for 108 psi at 350 °F (sheet 1 says 'see sheet 3 for calandria flanges').", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "SPECIFY STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASS 75 FLANGES RATED FOR 108 PSI AT 350 DEG F."},
  {"n": 13, "area": "geometry", "check": "Evaporator shell size, section heights and heads", "answer": "All three drawings show the same shell: 2'-6\" I.D.; calandria 2'-0\" between the upper and lower tubesheets; body 9'-0\" from upper tubesheet to a bolted body flange (RFSO); top section 1'-6\" from body flange to top of head; top head flanged and dished, bottom head 2:1 elliptical; four support lugs at the lower tubesheet. Data sheets agree on heads (top STD F&D, bottom 2:1 ELLIP) and V-2/V-3 give shell diam. 2'6\" (V-1 sheet leaves it blank).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "quote": "2'-6\" I.D.; 2'-0\"; 9'-0\"; BODY FLANGE (RFSO); 1'-6\"; F&D HEAD; 2:1 ELLIPTICAL HEAD [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 14, "area": "nozzles", "check": "V-1 nozzle schedule (data sheet)", "answer": "Vapor outlet B 6\"; steam inlet Q 4\"; vent A 2\"; condensate out R 2\"; juice in S1-2 two 1-1/2\"; juice outlet T 1-1/2\"; sight glasses J1-J4 four 5\" Class 150 studding flanges; level H1-H2 two 2\" Class 150 studding outlets; level transmitter V1-2 two 2\"; flanged nozzles ANSI Class 150 RFSO, threaded couplings ANSI Class 3000 incl. eleven 3/4\" spares Z1-Z11 with plugs; all 304 SS.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 294", "quote": "Q 4 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS STEAM INLET"},
  {"n": 15, "area": "nozzles", "check": "V-2 nozzle differences (data sheet)", "answer": "Vapor outlet B 6\" and steam inlet Q 6\"; two 1\" sample circulation nozzles U1-2; otherwise as V-1. Note 2 adds 26 x 3/4\" and 2 x 1-1/4\" threaded couplings ANSI 3000# 'see evaporator drawing'.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 298", "quote": "Q 6 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS STEAM INLET"},
  {"n": 16, "area": "nozzles", "check": "V-3 nozzle differences (data sheet)", "answer": "Vapor out A 8\"; equalization line B 2\"; steam inlet Q 6\"; U 1\" juice recycle; V1-2 two 2\" listed as spare with plug; no mark P on the data sheet; note 2 adds the same 26 x 3/4\" and 2 x 1-1/4\" threaded couplings as V-2.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 302", "quote": "A 8 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS VAPOR OUT"},
  {"n": 17, "area": "nozzles", "check": "Sight glasses", "answer": "Four 5\" sight glasses per evaporator (12 total): Papailias NW150 with Type II spray washer, 304 SS body, ANSI Class 150, tempered borosilicate window; the no. 4 glass on each evaporator (SG-1-4, 2-4, 3-4) also gets a light, the other nine only the spray wash.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 29", "quote": "SG-1-4, 2-4, AND 3-4 HAVE BOTH THE SPRAY WASH AND THE LIGHT"},
  {"n": 18, "area": "supports", "check": "Vessel supports", "answer": "Spec: each vessel has four pedestal lug supports designed for the vessel weight when completely filled to the dome vapor outlet with 60+ Brix syrup. Drawings show four support lugs at 45°, 135°, 225°, 315°. The data sheets mark LEGS (see contradictions).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 6", "quote": "Each vessel shall include four pedestal lug supports designed to support the vessel weight"},
  {"n": 19, "area": "supports", "check": "Lifting attachments", "answer": "Each vessel gets suitable lifting attachments for offloading and erection; data sheets mark lifting lugs YES (V-2 and V-3 location TOP; V-1 location blank).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 6", "quote": "Each vessel shall have suitable lifting attachments for offloading and erection."},
  {"n": 20, "area": "testing", "check": "Hydrostatic test", "answer": "Each compartment of the vessel hydrotested to 1.3x MAWP per ASME VIII UG-99(b), held at least 30 minutes, test water at ambient temperature, leaks clearly visible. No numeric MAWP is given anywhere; the calandria sheet lists test pressures of 75 psig shell side and 120 psig tube side (see contradictions).", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 7", "quote": "Hydrotesting shall be conducted on each compartment of the vessel to 1.3x MAWP as per"},
  {"n": 21, "area": "testing", "check": "Hold points and inspection", "answer": "Hold points: hydrotest witnessed by American Ingenuity; vacuum test witnessed by American Ingenuity; final assembly inspection at vendor's shop by American Ingenuity and LSU AgCenter before shipment. Periodic shop inspections are not hold points. Five days' notice before hold-point tests and inspections.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 7", "quote": "Vacuum test shall be witnessed and documented by a representative of American Ingenuity. This is a Hold Point."},
  {"n": 22, "area": "testing", "check": "Positive material identification and other skid testing", "answer": "Skid no. 1 sheet: PMI required YES; hydrostatic testing of piping YES; instrumentation and electrical testing YES; factory or site testing NO; additional requirement to test the system for vacuum time to third effect operating pressure.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 361", "quote": "POSITIVE MATERIAL IDENTIFICATION (PMI) REQUIRED: [ ] NO [X] YES [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 23, "area": "fabrication", "check": "Stress relief / PWHT", "answer": "V-2 and V-3 data sheets: stress relief NO. V-1 data sheet leaves the stress relief boxes unmarked.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 297", "quote": "STRESS RELIEF: [X] NO [ ] YES PER CODE [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 24, "area": "fabrication", "check": "Radiography", "answer": "V-2 and V-3 data sheets: radiograph 'PER CODE' (printed in red; the NO and YES boxes are unmarked). V-1 data sheet selects nothing for radiography.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 297", "quote": "RADIOGRAPH: [ ] NO [ ] YES PER CODE (PER CODE in red) [quote read from image]"},
  {"n": 25, "area": "coating", "check": "Painting and cleaning of the vessels", "answer": "Painting is not required (data sheets: paint NONE). Vessels drained, dried and cleaned inside before shipping; exterior cleaned of weld marks, spatter, grease and oil.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 7", "quote": "Painting is not required."},
  {"n": 26, "area": "coating", "check": "Insulation", "answer": "Insulation by vendor (data sheet box BY VENDOR marked): Aerogel with aluminum sheathing. Design detail 7: all insulation protected by ASTM C1729 aluminum jacketing 0.016 in thick; thicknesses TBD and should be less than 0.5 in with Aerogel; owner reviews installation details first.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 28", "quote": "ALL INSULATION SHALL BE PROTECTED BY ASTM C1729 ALUMINUM JACKETING, 0.016 INCHES THICK."},
  {"n": 27, "area": "scope", "check": "Mist eliminator in each evaporator", "answer": "Munters model DV270 (T271) droplet separator, one section, 304 SS, in each evaporator; support per manufacturer's recommendation; maximum pressure drop 0.1 psi.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 296", "quote": "MUNTERS MODEL DV270 (T271) DROPLET SEPARATOR - ONE SECTION"},
  {"n": 28, "area": "documents", "check": "Submittals and final documents", "answer": "Design documentation and drawings submitted for approval before fabrication (allow one week review); weld procedures and welder qualifications with the approval drawings (p. 7); two sets of final record drawings, parts lists and data before shipment; as-built drawing and data package in the schedule; spec sheets completed and returned at the end.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 8", "quote": "Design documentation and drawings shall be submitted for approval prior to the start of fabrication. Allow (1) week for review and approval."},
  {"n": 29, "area": "commercial", "check": "Pricing basis of the bid", "answer": "Lump-sum proposal for a firm fixed price contract, with a cost breakdown and a preliminary schedule (milestones and durations for engineering, purchasing materials and fabrication), plus a written list of issues and scope limitations submitted with the bid.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 8", "quote": "The vendor shall be required to submit a lump sum proposal with an appropriate cost breakdown and preliminary schedule for this firm fixed price contract."},
  {"n": 30, "area": "commercial", "check": "Delivery point and terms", "answer": "Delivered to LSU AgCenter Audubon Sugar Institute, 3845 Hwy 75, St. Gabriel, LA 70776; American Ingenuity notified 5 days before shipment; instruments, valves and insulation protected in transit; installation by others. No required delivery date is given; the vendor provides the schedule.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 8", "quote": "delivered to the LSU Agricultural Center Audubon Sugar Institute located at 3845 Hwy 75 St. Gabriel, LA 70776."},
  {"n": 31, "area": "commercial", "check": "Payment terms", "answer": "Not stated for this contract. Full text layer searched (payment, retainage, warranty, bond, liquidated, FOB, net 30); the only payment terms in the file belong to a third-party refractometer quotation (p. 97). Image-only pages were checked by thumbnail and are vendor brochures, curves and calculations. Spec 11.0 refers to separate 'Bid Documents' that are not in the package.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 8", "quote": "Refer to Bid Documents for proper submission of Requests for Information (RFI’s) and Requests for"},
  {"n": 32, "area": "documents", "check": "Calandria internal juice collection chamber drawing", "answer": "Referenced on the calandria sheet of all three evaporators as drawing 15-012-M-002, but not in the package: the drawing index on the title sheet (p. 11, read from image) lists only 15-012-100, 15-012-101, P&ID-01 to -04 and M-001-1/-2/-3, and the text layer has no other mention of M-002.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "quote": "SEE DRAWING 15-012-M-002 FOR CALANDRIA INTERNAL JUICE COLLECTION CHAMBER."},
  {"n": 33, "area": "scope", "check": "Condensate tanks T-1 to T-4", "answer": "Four tanks: T-1, T-2, T-3 (spec sheets pp. 282-284) and T-4 (design detail 11: identical in size to T-1/2/3). Each 1'-6\" diameter, vertical, shop fabricated, 304 SS shell/roof/bottom, zero corrosion allowance, designed for full vacuum/14 psig, design temperature 300 °F, support legs bolted to the skid, Aerogel insulation on sides only, no painting, grounding and lifting lugs.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 282", "quote": "DESIGN FOR FULL VACUUM/14 PSIG. SEE DESIGN DETAIL NO. 2 AND PLAN VIEW DWG. FOR NOZZLES."},
  {"n": 34, "area": "scope", "check": "Vacuum condenser E-1", "answer": "TEMA type BEU, ASME Section VIII and TEMA Class C. Shell side (saturated steam) design FV/50 psig, test 75 psig, 300 °F, corrosion allowance 0.0625 in; tube side (water) 100 psig, test 150 psig, 150 °F, CA 0; 304 SS shell, channel and seamless 0.750 in OD tubes; minimum 150 sq ft surface; fabricator calculates starred data and installs Aerogel insulation with 0.016 in aluminum jacketing.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 359", "quote": "Design/Test Pressure psig FV/50 / 75 100 / 150"},
  {"n": 35, "area": "scope", "check": "Skid general arrangement", "answer": "Skid no. 1 is shown 18'-0\" long by 9'-3 3/4\" wide with platform, railings and caged ladder; all equipment, piping, valves and instruments on the P&ID are included and fully assembled at the vendor's shop (spec 3.1, 3.5). The GA is for footprint and illustration only, not for fabrication.", "evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 12", "quote": "DRAWING IS FOR FOOTPRINT AND GENERAL ILLUSTRATION PURPOSE ONLY. DO NOT FABRICATE FROM THIS DRAWING."}
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {"topic": "Evaporator support type", "side_a": "Data sheets V-1, V-2, V-3 mark the LEGS box for supports: \"SUPPORTS: [X] LEGS [ ] LUGS [ ] SKIRT [ ] SADDLES\" (quote read from image; same on pp. 297 and 301).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 293", "side_b": "Spec 3.6: \"Each vessel shall include four pedestal lug supports designed to support the vessel weight\"; the drawings (pp. 17-19, read from image) label four \"SUPPORT LUG\" at 45°, 135°, 225°, 315°.", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 6", "why_it_matters": "Legs and side lugs are different attachments with different design loads (vessel full of 60+ Brix syrup), material and welding.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Flanged nozzle type and flange material", "side_a": "Data sheet nozzle schedule: \"B 6 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS VAPOR OUTLET\" (all flanged nozzles RFSO, 304 SS); sheet 1 line 31 \"FLANGES: ASTM A182 304 SS\" (p. 293).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 294", "side_b": "Drawing general note 1 (same on pp. 18-19): \"CONNECTIONS FLANGED TO BE 150# RFWN, SA-105\" (quote read from image).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "Slip-on versus weld neck and A182 304 SS versus SA-105 forgings change the cost of every flanged nozzle on three vessels.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Which calandria side is rated 80 psig", "side_a": "Calandria sheet: \"HOT SIDE - SHELL SIDE\" is steam and \"COLD SIDE - TUBE SIDE\" is sugar cane juice, with \"DESIGN PRESSURE PSIG 50 PSIG/FV 80 PSIG/FV\" (shell 50, tube 80); sheet 1 gives the sugar juice vessel 50 psig.", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "side_b": "Drawing design data: body \"=50 psig / FV\"; \"CALANDRIA DESIGN PRESSURE =80 psig\" with calandria material \"SS 304 SHELL, NOZZ & TUBESHEET\" (quote read from image), i.e. the calandria shell at 80 psig and no full-vacuum rating.", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "Whether the calandria shell or the juice side carries 80 psig (and whether the calandria needs a full-vacuum rating) sets calandria shell and tubesheet thickness and the test pressures.", "status": "likely"},
  {"topic": "Hydrotest pressure basis", "side_a": "Spec 5.1: \"Hydrotesting shall be conducted on each compartment of the vessel to 1.3x MAWP as per\" ASME VIII UG-99(b).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 7", "side_b": "Calandria sheet: \"TEST PRESSURE PSIG 75 PSIG 120 PSIG\" against design pressures of 50 and 80 psig (1.5 times design).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 295", "why_it_matters": "No MAWP number is given; if MAWP equals design pressure the spec gives 65/104 psig, not 75/120 psig, which changes test setup and possibly thickness. Marked likely because MAWP is never stated.", "status": "likely"},
  {"topic": "Temperature transmitter connections G and P", "side_a": "Data sheet: \"G 1 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG.\" temperature transmitter (P is also a 1\" RFSO flange on V-1 and V-2; the V-3 sheet has no mark P at all, p. 302).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 294", "side_b": "Drawing nozzle schedule: \"G | 1 | 1\" | CPLG. | TEMPERATURE TRANSMITTER\" and \"P | 1 | 1\" | CPLG. | TEMPERATURE TRANSMITTER\" (quote read from image; same on V-2 p. 18 and V-3 p. 19).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "Flanged nozzle versus threaded coupling changes the connection count and cost, and V-3 may be missing a connection on its data sheet.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Calandria vent L size and quantity", "side_a": "Data sheet row: \"L 1 0.75 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS CALANDRIA VENT\" (size 1 in, number 0.75; same on pp. 298 and 302).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 294", "side_b": "Drawing nozzle schedule: \"L | 1 | 3/4\" | FLG. | CALANDRIA VENT\" (quote read from image).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "The data sheet row is internally garbled (quantity 0.75) and gives a 1 in size against the drawing's 3/4 in.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Number of water nozzles", "side_a": "Data sheet lists one water nozzle: \"K 1 1 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS WATER IN\" (same on V-2 and V-3).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 294", "side_b": "Drawing nozzle schedule lists two: \"K1 | 1 | 1\" | FLG. | WATER\" and \"K2 | 1 | 1\" | FLG. | WATER\" (quote read from image; same on pp. 18-19).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "One extra 1 in flanged nozzle per evaporator.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "V-2 pressure gauge connection M", "side_a": "V-2 data sheet: \"M 0.75 1 ANSI CLASS 3000/THRD. CLPG.\" pressure/vacuum indicator.", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 298", "side_b": "V-2 drawing nozzle schedule: \"M | 1 | 3/4\" | FLG. | PRESSURE / VACUUM GAUGE\" (quote read from image; V-1 and V-3 drawings show M as CPLG).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 18", "why_it_matters": "Threaded coupling versus flanged nozzle for one connection on V-2.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "V-3 nozzles V1/V2 service", "side_a": "V-3 data sheet: \"V1-2 2 2 ANSI CLASS 150/ RFSO FLG. 304 SS SPARE WITH PLUG\".", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 302", "side_b": "V-3 drawing nozzle schedule: \"V1/V2 | 2 | 2\" | FLG. | LEVEL TRANSMITTER\" (quote read from image).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 19", "why_it_matters": "Same size and type, so little price effect, but it decides whether the nozzles get blind/plugs or an instrument.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Extra threaded couplings on V-2 and V-3", "side_a": "V-2 and V-3 data sheet note 2: \"EVAPORATOR ALSO HAS 26 3/4\" THREADED COUPINGS AND 2 1-1/4\" THREADED COUPINGS ANSI 3000 #. SEE\" evaporator drawing (same on p. 302).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 298", "side_b": "V-2 drawing nozzle schedule shows only \"Z1 / Z11 | 11 | 3/4\" | CPLG. | SPARE W/ PLUG\" plus C and D 3/4\" couplings, and no 1-1/4\" connection (quote read from image; V-3 p. 19 similar).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 18", "why_it_matters": "28 extra couplings per vessel are not shown on the drawing; they may belong to the missing M-002 drawing, so the count is unresolved.", "status": "likely"},
  {"topic": "Calandria sheet tagged to the wrong evaporator", "side_a": "V-2 calandria sheet description: \"DESCRIPTION: EVAPORATOR V-1 CALANDRIA\" (the V-3 sheet, p. 303, says the same).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 299", "side_b": "Same sheet header: \"EQUIPMENT NO.: V-2\", with V-2 process data (573 lb/hr steam).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 299", "why_it_matters": "A reader must decide which calandria the sheet's performance data belong to.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Sight glass orientation", "side_a": "Sight glass sheet SP-V-1-1-3: \"LOCATION: EVAPORATOR NO. 1 - 90 DEGREES\" (V-2 and V-3 sheets, pp. 309 and 311, also 90 degrees).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 306", "side_b": "V-1 orientation view places \"J1 J2 J3\" at \"180°\" (and steam inlet Q at 90°) (quote read from image; V-2 and V-3 drawings the same).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "Nozzle orientation must be fixed before layout; little direct price effect.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Upper shell length", "side_a": "Insulation schedule: \"EVAPORATOR NO. 1 TOP SHELL 2'-6\" X 11'7\"\" (same for evaporators 2 and 3).", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 28", "side_b": "Drawing: \"9'-0\"\" from upper tubesheet to body flange and \"1'-6\"\" from body flange to top of head (quote read from image), 10'-6\" in total above the tubesheet.", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 17", "why_it_matters": "An 11'-7\" top shell does not fit in the drawn 10'-6\" upper section; shell plate and insulation quantities depend on which is right. Marked likely because the insulation schedule may use a different basis.", "status": "likely"},
  {"topic": "Skid structure finish", "side_a": "Spec 6.4: \"Skid structure is to be Hot Dip Galvanized after fabrication.\" and 6.3 \"Painting is not required.\"", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 7", "side_b": "Skid no. 1 sheet: \"PAINTED CARBON STEEL SKID WITH OPEN GALVANIZED STEEL GRATING.\" with a three-coat paint scheme for uninsulated carbon steel.", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 361", "why_it_matters": "Hot-dip galvanizing versus a three-coat paint system is a different cost and subcontract for the whole skid.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "Pressure vessel code named on the skid sheet", "side_a": "Spec 2.0: \"ASME B&PV Code Section VIII, Div. 1\".", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 6", "side_b": "Skid no. 1 sheet: \"PRESSURE VESSELS: DESIGN PER ASME SECTION VII, DIV, 1.\" (skid no. 2 sheet, p. 362, the same).", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 361", "why_it_matters": "Almost certainly a typo for Section VIII, but the skid sheet literally names a different code section.", "status": "confirmed"},
  {"topic": "T-5 separator supports", "side_a": "T-5 sheet construction block: \"SUPPORT TYPE: SKIRT\".", "side_a_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 360", "side_b": "Same sheet, special requirements: \"VERTICAL SHALL BE SUPPORTED BY FOUR ANGLE LEGS WITH 18 IN. CLEARANCE FROM BOTTOM TO BASE.\"", "side_b_evidence": "ASI_Evaporators_Renovation_Project_Package.pdf, p. 360", "why_it_matters": "Skirt versus four angle legs changes the support fabrication of the separator.", "status": "confirmed"}
 ]
}
