{
 "id": "us-madison-pfas-gac-vessels",
 "country": "United States",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "City of Madison, Wisconsin - Madison Water Utility (engineer: AECOM)",
 "project": "Unit Well 15 PFAS Treatment Facility, Contract No. 9342 (Project No. 14092): four GAC / ion exchange pressure vessels inside a general construction contract",
 "year": "2024",
 "files": [
  {
   "file": "9342 Technical Specifications.pdf",
   "pages": 432,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Technical specifications (AECOM, Dec 2023); vessel section 44 43 31 on pp. 412-421, Summary of Work 01 11 00 on pp. 9-10"
  },
  {
   "file": "9342 Plans.pdf",
   "pages": 55,
   "text_layer": false,
   "what_it_is": "Bid drawings, Dec 2023, outlined vector text with no text layer; P&IDs 09-N-01/02 on pp. 18-19, process sheets 10-D-01 to 10-D-06 on pp. 37-42"
  },
  {
   "file": "9342 Contract.pdf",
   "pages": 55,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Proposal, agreement, bonds, special provisions (American Iron and Steel), Davis-Bacon provisions and wage rates; the priced bid form is on Bid Express and not in the file"
  },
  {
   "file": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf",
   "pages": 52,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 3 (Jan 23, 2024): pre-bid meeting minutes and Q&A (pp. 3-13), air stripper brochure, reissued 01 11 00, 01 25 00, 01 33 00 and 44 43 31 with tracked changes (44 43 31 on pp. 41-50), two reissued plan sheets"
  },
  {
   "file": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf",
   "pages": 35,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 4 (Feb 5, 2024): reissued 40 23 13.01 and 44 43 31 with tracked changes (44 43 31 on pp. 20-29), six reissued plan sheets with a text layer (pp. 30-35)"
  },
  {
   "file": "9342 Addendum 5.pdf",
   "pages": 11,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 5 (Feb 6, 2024): replaces Section K Davis-Bacon wage rates only"
  }
 ],
 "quality": "All vessel requirements sit in one 10-page spec section reissued twice with tracked changes, where struck and inserted text share the text layer (the safety factor reads \"43.5\"); the drawings are outlined vector text with no text layer, and no numeric design pressure or temperature appears anywhere.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "GAC vessels T-1 and T-2: two vertical ASME VIII stamped pressure filters, 12 ft diameter, SA-516 Gr 70, 20,000 lb GAC capacity each, NSF 61 epoxy-lined, 316 SS internals",
  "Ion exchange vessels T-3 and T-4: two vertical pressure filters of the same 12 ft size downstream of the GAC vessels, minimum 340 cu ft resin at 3 ft depth",
  "Package items in the same section: internals, motor-actuated butterfly valves (four actuators), air/vacuum release valves, piping to vessel isolation valves, expansion joints, loss-of-head gauge panels, GAC and IX media, spare parts, factory field services"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "n": 1,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "How many pressure vessels, and which services?",
   "answer": "Four vertical pressure filter vessels (2.03.A.2, unchanged in the Addendum 4 reissue): two GAC vessels and two ion exchange vessels (Section 01 11 00 as reissued in Addendum 3).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 23",
   "quote": "Number of Vessels: 4 | two GAC vessels, two ion exchange vessels"
  },
  {
   "n": 2,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Vessel tags",
   "answer": "GAC vessels T-1 and T-2 (P&ID 09-N-01); ion exchange vessels T-3 and T-4 (P&ID 09-N-02), fed from the GAC vessel outlets.",
   "evidence": "9342 Plans.pdf, p. 18 (quote read from image); p. 19 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "GAC T-1 | GAC T-2 | IX TANK T-3 | IX TANK T-4"
  },
  {
   "n": 3,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Hydraulic design conditions",
   "answer": "Design flow 700 gpm; working pressure less than 100 psi; maximum loading rate 6.2 gpm/ft2.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Design Flow, gpm: 700 | Working Pressure, psi: less than 100 | Maximum Loading Rate, gpm/ft2: 6.2"
  },
  {
   "n": 4,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "ASME stamp pressure",
   "answer": "ASME code stamp at 100 psi or higher (2.03.A.5.d). Added by Addendum 3 after a pre-bid question asked whether the stamp should be 125 psi; kept in the governing Addendum 4 reissue.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 45 (quote read from image); p. 7",
   "quote": "100 psi or higher ASME code with stamp. | ASME Stamp may be 100 psi or higher."
  },
  {
   "n": 5,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Design pressure (as a number), design temperature, corrosion allowance, radiography, PWHT, impact testing, National Board registration",
   "answer": "None of these is stated. The governing text gives only working pressure \"less than 100\" psi and a stamp of \"100 psi or higher\", although the Addendum 3 cover says design pressure was clarified. Searched the full text layer of the spec, contract and Addenda 3 to 5, and viewed P&IDs 09-N-01/02 and process sheets 10-D-01 to 10-D-06.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 2",
   "quote": "Clarifications on ASME pressure, design pressure, and media volume minimums are provided."
  },
  {
   "n": 6,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Design safety factor (governing addendum)",
   "answer": "3.5, per Addendum 4 (tracked change strikes \"4\" and inserts \"3.5\"). The original spec and the Addendum 3 reissue said 4.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); 9342 Technical Specifications.pdf, p. 416; 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 45 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Design with safety factor of 3.5. | Design with safety factor of 4. | Design with pressure safety factor of 4."
  },
  {
   "n": 7,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "Factory pressure test (governing addendum)",
   "answer": "Factory test per ASME standards, per Addendum 4. The earlier \"to 50 percent above design system pressure\" is struck.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Factory test per ASME standards."
  },
  {
   "n": 8,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "Construction code and stamp",
   "answer": "ASME Section VIII \"cold fired pressure vessels\", bearing the ASME stamp.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "constructed in accordance with Section VIII of the ASME code requirements for cold fired pressure vessels, and bear the ASME stamp."
  },
  {
   "n": 9,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "Fabricator certification",
   "answer": "Shop must hold a current ASME U-stamp; ASME R (repair) or other certificates are not acceptable.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Vessels shall be fabricated in a facility holding a current ASME U-stamp. Facilities holding an ASME R (“repair”) or other certification are not acceptable."
  },
  {
   "n": 10,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "Calculations before fabrication",
   "answer": "Calculated head and shell thicknesses (verification of ASME design) go with the first submittal drawing and must be approved by the Engineer Representative before fabrication is authorized.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Verification of ASME code design to include calculated head and shell thicknesses. Submit with the first submittal drawing"
  },
  {
   "n": 11,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Vessel diameter and filter area",
   "answer": "12 ft diameter; minimum filtering area 113.1 ft2 per filter.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Minimum Filtering Area/Filter, feet2: 113.1 | Filter size: 12 feet diameter"
  },
  {
   "n": 12,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Media capacity per vessel",
   "answer": "20,000 lb GAC capacity; ion exchange: 3 minute minimum contact time, 3 ft minimum media depth, minimum 340 cu ft (the 340 cu ft appears as an inserted tracked change).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "20,000 lb capacity GAC media | 3 minute minimum IX media contact time. | 3 foot minimum IX media depth (minimum 340 cubic feet)."
  },
  {
   "n": 13,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Maximum overall height",
   "answer": "No height number in the spec; it points to the drawings. Process Section C (10-D-05, reissued in Addendum 4) shows top of tank pad EL. 888.83 and bottom of precast roof EL. 907.50. The on-site pre-bid Q&A (Addendum 3, p. 13) says the drawings give adequate height information.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); p. 34; 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 13",
   "quote": "Maximum overall height – see drawings | B/PRECAST EL. 907.50 | T.O. PAD EL. 888.83 | Clarification on the tank height was requested."
  },
  {
   "n": 14,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Shell and head material",
   "answer": "Welded steel construction, SA-516 Grade 70.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Material: Welded Steel Construction: | SA-516 Grade 70 steel."
  },
  {
   "n": 15,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Weld and flange requirements",
   "answer": "All flanges, plates, angles, channels and beams, including shell-to-head joints, full penetration welded both sides with continuous welding; flanges factory welded on split centers.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "including side shell to head connections, joined by full penetration welds, each side, continuous welding. | Flanges: Factory welded on split centers."
  },
  {
   "n": 16,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Internals material",
   "answer": "Influent/collection system is the manufacturer's standard design; metal internals 316 stainless steel Schedule 10 or heavier, compatible with media; no Teflon tape (tracked insertions first made in Addendum 3, kept in Addendum 4).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image); 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 46 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Metals internals shall be 316 Stainless Steel Schedule 10 or higher. | Use of teflon tape on internal systems is prohibited."
  },
  {
   "n": 17,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Underdrain / support gravel",
   "answer": "No support gravel: media sits directly on the collection system and the collection headers must be self-supporting.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 26 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "In lieu of support gravel, GAC or IX media shall be used, respectively, and collection headers shall be self-supporting."
  },
  {
   "n": 18,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Manways (governing addendum)",
   "answer": "Manholes at the top above the media and at the bottom of each vessel, each with a spare gasket, minimum 14 in x 18 in (Addendum 4 governing text; the original 12 x 16 is struck on the same page).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "at both the top above the media and the bottom. Provide with spare gasket. Minimum 14 inches x 18 inches manway."
  },
  {
   "n": 19,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Connections shown on the P&IDs",
   "answer": "Per vessel: 10 in process piping at top and bottom, 4 in media fill, 4 in media discharge at the bottom head, 3/4 in utility air/water, four 1/2 in sample ports, an air release valve symbol on the top piping. The same set is drawn for IX tanks T-3 and T-4 on P&ID 09-N-02.",
   "evidence": "9342 Plans.pdf, p. 18 (quote read from image); p. 19 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "4\" MEDIA FILL | 1/2\" SAMPLE PORTS | 3/4\" UTILITY AIR/WATER | MEDIA DISCHARGE | IX TANK T-3"
  },
  {
   "n": 20,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Leveling / jacklegs (governing addendum)",
   "answer": "Addendum 4 deletes 2.03.A.7 \"Adjustable cast iron jacklegs\" (Addendum 3 had allowed jacklegs \"or other methods\") and adds 3.01.B \"Mount tanks level.\" No jackleg requirement governs.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); p. 28 (quote read from image); 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 45 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Adjustable cast iron jacklegs. | Mount tanks level. | or other methods to adjust height for level installation."
  },
  {
   "n": 21,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Anchor bolts",
   "answer": "Type 316 stainless anchor bolts and hardware.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 25 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Provide Type 316 anchor bolts and hardware."
  },
  {
   "n": 22,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Surface preparation",
   "answer": "Interior sandblast to SSPC-SP10 (near white); exterior SSPC-SP6 (commercial).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 27",
   "quote": "Interior - Sandblast to near white blast cleaning (SSPC-SP10). | Exterior - Sandblast to commercial blast cleaning (SSPC-SP6)."
  },
  {
   "n": 23,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Interior lining system",
   "answer": "NSF 61 approved Tnemec Pota-Pox: stripe coat tank white 3-5 mils, beige primer 3-5 mils, finish tank white 4-6 mils; total 7-11 mils DFT.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 27",
   "quote": "NSF Std. 61 approved. | Tnemec pota-pox tank white to a dry mil thickness of 4-6 mils for a total dry film thickness of 7-11 mils."
  },
  {
   "n": 24,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Exterior coating",
   "answer": "Shop: stripe coat Tnemec Series 20 tank white 3-5 mils and Series 20 beige primer 3-5 mils. Exterior finish coat applied by others.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 28 (quote read from image)",
   "quote": "Tnemec Series 20 Beige primer | The exterior finish coat shall be applied by others with compatible system."
  },
  {
   "n": 25,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Package scope boundary",
   "answer": "One manufacturer furnishes the whole section, including butterfly, ball and air release valves and piping up to the vessel isolation valves; Addendum 3 adds that the Contractor carries all piping and valves in the drawings even where the vendor does not supply them.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 22 (quote read from image); 9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 2",
   "quote": "Piping shall include all piping to vessel isolation valves. | Contractor is responsible for all piping and valves within drawing set"
  },
  {
   "n": 26,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Named manufacturers and alternates",
   "answer": "Calgon Carbon or AqueoUS Vets; Addendum 4 lets other vendors bid if they have written approval that they meet the same criteria and sizing.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image); p. 1",
   "quote": "Calgon Carbon. | AqueoUS Vets. | other vendors may provide bids if they have written approval that they meet the same criteria and sizing standards listed."
  },
  {
   "n": 27,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Media supply",
   "answer": "GAC: Calgon Carbon, 40,000 lbs total, 12x40 mesh, NSF 61 (product named both C400 and F400, see contradictions). IX: Purolite PFA 694 E or Dow PSR 2+, NSF 61. Both installed in the field; Addendum 4 says no other media are acceptable.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 26 (quote read from image); p. 1",
   "quote": "C400 Calgon Carbon GAC media per 2 vessels (40,000 lbs total) | other GAC media or ion exchange media are not acceptable."
  },
  {
   "n": 28,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Field service days",
   "answer": "Factory-trained technician on site: installation 2, functional testing 4, performance testing 2, training 1 person-days, exclusive of travel; unused days credited at the published rate; extra time to fix deficiencies at no cost.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 23",
   "quote": "Person-day requirements listed are exclusive of travel time"
  },
  {
   "n": 29,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Domestic content",
   "answer": "All materials must meet Buy America - Build America (BABA); the contract also requires American Iron and Steel (AIS), all iron and steel produced in the United States, with AIS certification.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 20; 9342 Contract.pdf, p. 4",
   "quote": "All materials shall meet Buy America – Build America Act. | iron and steel products provided by the Contractor shall be produced in the United States"
  },
  {
   "n": 30,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Schedule constraints tied to the vessels",
   "answer": "Roof may not be removed until vessel delivery is confirmed; beneficial occupancy deadline June 30, 2025, with liquidated damages.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 24",
   "quote": "Do not remove roof until vessel delivery is confirmed. | Deadline for beneficial occupancy will be June 30, 2025."
  },
  {
   "n": 31,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Seismic calculations for the vessels",
   "answer": "Not required (Addendum 3 note; nothing added to the spec).",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 2",
   "quote": "Note – Seismic calculations are not required and not added to the specifications."
  },
  {
   "n": 32,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Which addendum governs the vessel section",
   "answer": "Addendum 4 (Feb 5, 2024) replaces Section 44 43 31 in its entirety and governs over the original and the Addendum 3 reissue; Addendum 5 (Feb 6, 2024) only replaces Section K wage rates and does not touch the vessels.",
   "evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 1; 9342 Addendum 5.pdf, p. 1",
   "quote": "Section 44 43 31 Pressure Filtration Equipment – GAC and Ion Exchange, REPLACE in its entirety. | Updated Davis-Bacon wage rates as of January 26, 2024"
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "topic": "Manway size in the original spec (resolved by addenda)",
   "side_a": "2.03.A.6: minimum 12 in x 16 in manway. Quote: \"Access manhole in each filter with spare gasket, Minimum 12 inches (300 mm) x 16 inches (400 mm) manway.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Technical Specifications.pdf, p. 416",
   "side_b": "2.03.D.1: 14 in x 18 in manways. Addenda 3 and 4 change 2.03.A.6 to 14 x 18, so 14 x 18 governs. Quote: \"Provide each filter cell equipped with a sufficient number of 14-inches (350 mm) x 18-inches (450 mm) manways\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Technical Specifications.pdf, p. 417",
   "why_it_matters": "Manway size and count (top and bottom) drive forging, reinforcement and cover cost; a reader of the original spec alone gets two sizes.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Design safety factor: 4 vs 3.5",
   "side_a": "Original spec (p. 416) and Addendum 3 reissue: safety factor 4. Quote: \"Design with pressure safety factor of 4.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 45 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Addendum 4 reissue: \"4\" struck, \"3.5\" inserted. Addendum 4 governs. Quote: \"Design with safety factor of 3.5.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "The safety factor sets plate thickness and weight for four 12 ft vessels; a reader of the text layer sees \"43.5\".",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Factory test pressure",
   "side_a": "Original spec and Addendum 3: test to 50 percent above design system pressure. Quote: \"Factory test to 50 percent above design system pressure.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Technical Specifications.pdf, p. 416",
   "side_b": "Addendum 4: factory test per ASME standards (the 50 percent text is struck). Addendum 4 governs. Quote: \"Factory test per ASME standards.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "The test pressure sets test equipment, blind flanges and possibly thickness; the two versions give different test pressures.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Jacklegs",
   "side_a": "Addendum 3: adjustable cast iron jacklegs or other leveling method (original spec p. 416: adjustable cast iron jacklegs). Quote: \"Adjustable cast iron jacklegs or other methods to adjust height for level installation.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 45 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "Addendum 4: the jackleg item is struck entirely (p. 24) and 3.01.B \"Mount tanks level.\" is added. Addendum 4 governs. Quote: \"Mount tanks level.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 28 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Cast iron jacklegs are a priced support item; under Addendum 4 the support/leveling method is the vendor's.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "GAC product name: C400 vs F400",
   "side_a": "2.04.A: C400 Calgon Carbon GAC. Quote: \"20,000 lbs of C400 Calgon Carbon GAC media\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 26 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "2.04.A.1 (same clause): F400 media. Same text in the original spec (p. 417). Quote: \"F400 Media\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 26 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Two different carbon products are named for 40,000 lbs of media, and Addendum 4 says no other media are acceptable, so the product must be confirmed before pricing media.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "GAC quantity basis",
   "side_a": "2.03.A.3.a: each filter has 20,000 lb GAC capacity. Quote: \"20,000 lb capacity GAC media\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 24 (quote read from image)",
   "side_b": "2.04.A: \"20,000 lbs ... per 2 vessels (40,000 lbs total)\". Quote: \"per 2 vessels (40,000 lbs total)\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 26 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Read literally, \"20,000 lbs per 2 vessels\" is 20,000 lbs for the pair while \"40,000 lbs total\" doubles it; the media line could be priced at either quantity.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Backwash in service",
   "side_a": "1.01.B: backwash is operated manually (3.02.B on p. 28 also says media installation includes GAC backwash and IX flushing). Quote: \"Media replacement and backwash will be operated manually.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 20",
   "side_b": "Addendum 4 cover note: no backwash after the media is in service. Quote: \"media will not be backwashed after being placed into service (backwash expansion is not critical)\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 1",
   "why_it_matters": "Backwash expansion sets freeboard and internals design; the section text and the cover note point different ways.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Loss-of-head gauge panel tags",
   "side_a": "2.08.A lists PI/PDIT 15-2 twice and no 15-3. Quote: \"PI/PDIT 15-1, PI/PDIT 15-2, PI/PDIT 15-2, and PI/PDIT 15-4.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 4.pdf, p. 27",
   "side_b": "P&ID 09-N-02 shows PDIT 15-3 on IX tank T-3. Quote: \"PDIT 15-3\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Plans.pdf, p. 19 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "Low price effect (four panels either way) but nameplates and wiring follow the tags.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Addendum 3 date",
   "side_a": "Cover letter date: January 23, 2023. Quote: \"January 23, 2023\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 1",
   "side_b": "Footer and signature: 1/23/2024. Quote: \"ADDENDUM 3 – 1/23/2024\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "9342 Addendum 3.pdf, p. 1",
   "why_it_matters": "No price effect; it only affects which addendum is read as latest if dates are trusted.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  }
 ]
}