{
 "id": "us-thornton-surge-tanks",
 "country": "United States",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "City of Thornton, Colorado",
 "project": "Thornton Water Project - Source Water Pump Station, IFB / Project No. 12-777XP (hydropneumatic surge tanks TNK-321 and TNK-322 with air compressor and receiver)",
 "year": "2026",
 "files": [
  {
   "file": "12-777xp-ifb-6-2-26.pdf",
   "pages": 140,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Invitation for Bid: bid form and schedule of pay items (Item 25 Surge Tanks, Surge Tank Concrete Vault, and Surge Tank Foundations), special conditions (tariff clause), general conditions (warranty)."
  },
  {
   "file": "12-777xp-addend-no1-6-12-26.pdf",
   "pages": 7,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 1 (June 15, 2026): new bid date; replaces drawings incl. 30S16-30S18, 30S20, 30M01-30M11, 30N30; Division 01 and other spec edits (nothing on 43 42 21)."
  },
  {
   "file": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf",
   "pages": 26,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 2 (July 2, 2026): deletes Section 43 42 21.08 and adds Section 43 42 21.12 Hydropneumatic Surge Control System Including Tank (pdf pp. 6-23, data table p. 11); pre-bid sign-in sheets (pp. 4-5, image only); revised 30M03 and 30GC02."
  },
  {
   "file": "12-777xp-addend-no3-7-14-26.pdf",
   "pages": 3,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 3 (July 14, 2026): replaces 30S11, 30M02, 30M03, 30M04, 30N09, 30N27-30N29 'under separate cover' (those sheets are not in this package); adds Volume 8 (not in package)."
  },
  {
   "file": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf",
   "pages": 37,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 4 (July 16, 2026): Q&A log (pp. 6-8, items 36-37 on the surge P&ID), coating QP 1 waiver, replaced 26 06 01 conduit schedule, revised sheets 30S09, 30E15 (p. 31), 30E19, 30N32 Surge Tanks and Compressor P&ID (p. 33), 50C01, 50C03, 50S06."
  },
  {
   "file": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf",
   "pages": 31,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Addendum 1 revised drawings: 30S17 surge tank plans (p. 13), 30S18 (p. 14), 30S20 (p. 15), 30M06 surge tank plan (p. 21), 30M07 (p. 22), 30M08 (p. 23), 30M09 mechanical details (p. 24), cathodic protection sheets."
  },
  {
   "file": "twp-swps_vol1of7_ifb_drawings_printready.pdf",
   "pages": 176,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Volume 1 IFB drawings (original): surge tank sheets 30S17-30S20 (pp. 69-72), 30M06-30M09 (pp. 78-81), 30E25 (p. 114), 30N32 (p. 135); most surge sheets later replaced by Addenda 1 and 4."
  },
  {
   "file": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf",
   "pages": 1718,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Volume 2 technical specifications Divisions 01-46: original Section 43 42 21.08 (pp. 1675-1686, deleted by Addendum 2), 01 20 20 pay items, 01 75 17 commissioning, 01 78 36 warranties, 01 81 50 design criteria, 09 96 01 coatings, 43 25 00.10 sump pumps, 46 05 94 equipment testing. About 100 blank separator pages have no text."
  },
  {
   "file": "twp-swps_vol5of7_owners-prepurchase.pdf",
   "pages": 72,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Volume 5 Owner's prepurchase agreements (pumps, VFDs, electrical gear); no surge tank content."
  }
 ],
 "quality": "The vessel section in the main spec volume (43 42 21.08, 150 psig, 24-inch manway, 60 percent air) was deleted and replaced by Addendum 2 (43 42 21.12), which gives design pressure only as rules, not a number; the surge drawings were reissued by Addenda 1 and 4 (one addendum's sheets are missing), and the drawings, P&ID and coating section still disagree with the new section on drain valve size, level instrument type, number of control panels and lining thickness.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "TNK-321 (Surge Tank 1): horizontal buried hydropneumatic surge vessel, 144 in diameter, 760 in minimum barrel length, 50,000 gal minimum, ASME VIII-1 stamped, raw water service",
  "TNK-322 (Surge Tank 2): identical to TNK-321",
  "Air compressor package: reciprocating air compressors (two compressor skids CMP-331A and CMP-331B on P&ID 30N32) with an ASME, National Board coded air receiver (80 gal minimum) and receiver-mounted compressor control panel VCP-331",
  "Level control system: radar level transmitter and backup level switch on each vessel, PLC vendor control panel(s) with LOI, add-air and release-air solenoid valves, vessel safety valves and vent valves",
  "Sump pumps PMP-321A/B and PMP-322A/B shown on the revised surge P&ID (supply responsibility ambiguous; specified separately in 43 25 00.10)"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "n": 1,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Which specification section governs the surge vessels?",
   "answer": "Section 43 42 21.12 Hydropneumatic Surge Control System Including Tank, added by Addendum 2. Addendum 2 deletes original Section 43 42 21.08 (Volume 2 pp. 1675-1686) in its entirety, so all values in 43 42 21.08 are superseded.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 3",
   "quote": "Section 43_42_21.08 - Hydropneumatic Pressure Control System Including Tank: Delete Section in its entirety."
  },
  {
   "n": 2,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Vessel tags, quantity and service",
   "answer": "Two vessels: TNK-321 and TNK-322 (Surge Tank 1 and Surge Tank 2 on 30M06), service listed as Raw Water.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "TNK-321 Raw Water 144 760 50,000 350 TNK-322 Raw Water 144 760 50,000 350"
  },
  {
   "n": 3,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Diameter, barrel length and capacity of each vessel",
   "answer": "Diameter 144 inches; barrel length 760 inches minimum; capacity 50,000 gallons minimum (each vessel, Addendum 2 data table).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Diameter minimum minimum Pressure I.D. No. Service (inches) (inches) (gallons) (psig) TNK-321 Raw Water 144 760 50,000 350"
  },
  {
   "n": 4,
   "area": "geometry",
   "check": "Orientation and head type",
   "answer": "Horizontal installation with semi-elliptical dished heads.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Vessel Orientation: Horizontal installation. 3. Vessel ends: Semi-elliptical dished heads."
  },
  {
   "n": 5,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Maximum operating pressure",
   "answer": "350 psig for each vessel (Addendum 2 data table, column 'Maximum Operating Pressure (psig)'). Note it is higher than the 330 psig maximum transient pressure stated in the same section (see contradictions).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Barrel Maximum Length, Capacity, Operating Diameter minimum minimum Pressure I.D. No. Service (inches) (inches) (gallons) (psig) TNK-321 Raw Water 144 760 50,000 350"
  },
  {
   "n": 6,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Maximum transient (surge) pressure",
   "answer": "330 psig maximum transient system pressure (surge design basis).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "quote": "Maximum transient system pressure: 330 psig."
  },
  {
   "n": 7,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Design pressure",
   "answer": "No single number is given. Design pressure must be not less than 75 psig above the 330 psig maximum transient pressure, and in no case less than 1.2 times the maximum operating pressure (350 psig in the data table). Arithmetic on the stated values: at least 405 psig and at least 420 psig, so the stricter floor is 420 psig. Supersedes the 150 psig design pressure in deleted Section 43 42 21.08.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Minimum design pressure shall be not less than 75 psig above the maximum transient system pressure specified in this Section."
  },
  {
   "n": 8,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Air volume / air-water basis",
   "answer": "Minimum air volume of 8,000 gallons within each surge vessel at operating conditions, maintained during all operating and transient conditions. Supersedes '60 percent air under steady state conditions' in deleted 43 42 21.08.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "quote": "Required minimum air volume: 8,000 gallons within the surge vessel at operating conditions."
  },
  {
   "n": 9,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Design temperature, MDMT and impact testing",
   "answer": "Not stated. No MDMT, vessel design temperature or impact-test requirement appears for the surge vessels (text layer of all nine files searched for MDMT, minimum design metal temperature, impact test, Charpy, design temperature; Charpy and 'Design Temperature: 40 degrees F' occur only in steel pipe Section 33 05 01.01). The only service data are buried soil temperature 40 to 85 F, relative humidity 10 to 100 percent and elevation 5,130 ft.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Soil temperature: 40 to 85 degrees Fahrenheit."
  },
  {
   "n": 10,
   "area": "code",
   "check": "Construction code and stamp",
   "answer": "ASME BPVC Section VIII, Division 1: designed, fabricated and stamped. Stainless steel ASME nameplate with the applicable code symbol; manufacturer must be authorized by ASME to apply the code stamp (2.02.C.3, p. 12).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "All surge vessels shall be designed, fabricated, and stamped in accordance with ASME BPVC Section VIII, Division 1."
  },
  {
   "n": 11,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "Data reports, inspection and National Board",
   "answer": "Form U-1 Manufacturer's Data Report certifying ASME fabrication and inspection by a certified inspector; after the Contractor's Engineer accepts it, copies go to the National Board and to the 'Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Industrial Safety, Pressure Vessel Section'. O&M manuals include Form U-1 and 'Vessel ASME Form U-1A' (shop testing); closeout requires confirmation of U-1 submittal to the National Board (p. 10). Receiver is separately 'ASME, National Board coded' (p. 15).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "quote": "submit copies to the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors and to the Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Industrial Safety"
  },
  {
   "n": 12,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Radiography and PWHT",
   "answer": "The ASME data reports in the O&M submittal must document post-weld heat treatment, joint radiography and hydrostatic testing. The extent of radiography (full or spot) and whether PWHT is required are not otherwise stated for the vessels (text layer of all files searched for radiograph, heat treat, PWHT, stress relieve; other hits are pipe and structural sections). This ambiguity is the answer.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "quote": "Certification and ASME Code data reports in accordance with ASME Code, documenting post-welding heat treatment, joint radiography, and hydrostatic testing."
  },
  {
   "n": 13,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Vessel plate material",
   "answer": "ASTM A516 steel unless otherwise indicated on the Drawings; no A516 grade is stated in 43 42 21.12, and the surge drawings give no other vessel material.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "quote": "Construct tank using ASTM A516 steel unless otherwise indicated on the Drawings."
  },
  {
   "n": 14,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "Corrosion allowance",
   "answer": "1/16 inch minimum for shell, heads and attachments.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Provide a minimum corrosion allowance of 1/16 inch for shell, heads, and attachments."
  },
  {
   "n": 15,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Burial and external loading design",
   "answer": "Vessels are designed for buried installation: minimum 6 ft soil cover, H-20 surface loading, deflection not over 2 percent, no buckling under all loading conditions, soil modulus E' of 1,000 psi unless otherwise demonstrated. Structural sheets 30S18/30S20 (Addendum 1) show the shells bedded in compacted pea gravel on a pier-supported slab with the head end inside a concrete vault.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Design vessel for buried installation with a minimum soil cover of 6 feet. b. Design for H-20 surface loading."
  },
  {
   "n": 16,
   "area": "documents",
   "check": "Design calculations and shop drawings required",
   "answer": "Structural design calculations for the pressure vessel showing deflection not over 2 percent and no buckling under burial, H-20 and operating pressure load cases; tank sizing, air volume and compressor sizing calculations; fabrication drawings with dimensions, wall thicknesses, supports and anchorage, and empty weight (1.04.B, pp. 7-8). Division 01 Section 01 81 50 (Vol 2 p. 197) requires delegated structural design by a Colorado-licensed PE and lists tank supports and anchorage.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Include calculations demonstrating that vessel deflection does not exceed 2 percent and that buckling criteria are not exceeded under all applicable load cases"
  },
  {
   "n": 17,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Who furnishes tank supports and anchors",
   "answer": "The tank manufacturer (structural sheets 30S17 and 30S18, Addendum 1). Anchor bolts 3/4 in minimum with chairs or rings designed for the lesser of 125 percent of bolt ultimate strength or 150 percent of calculated load (Addendum 2 p. 12); 30M07 (Addendum 1 p. 22) requires G10 isolation sleeves and washers at anchor bolts, which must not touch the tank legs.",
   "evidence": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 13 (sheet 30S17)",
   "quote": "TANK SUPPORT AND ANCHORS BY MFR."
  },
  {
   "n": 18,
   "area": "supports",
   "check": "Buoyancy / tie-down restraint",
   "answer": "Non-metallic tie-down straps furnished by the manufacturer (30S18 and 30S20 as revised by Addendum 1; the original sheets said only 'TIE DOWN STRAPS BY MFR.'). 30S17 gives a 100-year flood elevation of 5131 for buoyancy.",
   "evidence": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 14 (sheet 30S18)",
   "quote": "NON-METALLIC TIE DOWN STRAPS BY MFR."
  },
  {
   "n": 19,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Inlet/outlet connection",
   "answer": "One 18-inch ID inlet/outlet with a 90-degree downward-facing elbow and vortex suppressor, minimum 8-inch clearance from the vessel bottom, flanged connection to the exterior manifold, no air entrainment at minimum water level, loss coefficient K not over 2, supports for the inlet piping and elbow.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Provide one 18-inch inside diameter inlet/outlet connection. b. Provide a 90-degree downward-facing elbow with vortex suppressor."
  },
  {
   "n": 20,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Drain connection",
   "answer": "8-inch drain connection with an 8-inch plug valve per Addendum 2 (drawing 30M08 tags 4-inch plug valves at the drains; see contradictions).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "quote": "Drain: Provide 8-inch drain connection with 8-inch plug valve."
  },
  {
   "n": 21,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Manway / inspection opening",
   "answer": "One 42-inch diameter minimum inspection opening with bolted cover and gasket rated for full design pressure, lifting lugs on cover and shell; 30M09 Detail 4 (Addendum 1) shows a '42\" BLIND FLANGE' referenced from the head on 30M06. Supersedes the 24-inch opening in deleted 43 42 21.08.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "quote": "Provide one 42-inch diameter minimum inspection opening."
  },
  {
   "n": 22,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Connection types and reinforcement",
   "answer": "Openings larger than 1 inch flanged; 1 inch and smaller NPT; all openings reinforced per ASME BPVC; fittings as indicated on the Drawings; shell attachments for pipe supports, gauges and instruments welded before lining. 30M06 notes: all tank connections dielectrically separated from connected piping; instrument connections located by the tank manufacturer.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "quote": "Openings larger than 1 inch shall be flanged. c. Openings 1 inch and smaller shall be NPT."
  },
  {
   "n": 23,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Level instrument connections on the vessel",
   "answer": "Radar level transmitter mounted on each vessel, rated for not less than vessel design pressure, plus one independent high/low level switch as backup (P&ID 30N32 shows LIT/LE-321-01 PTOF and LSH/LE-321-02 tuning fork, same for TNK-322).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 13",
   "quote": "Level measurement shall be provided by a radar level transmitter mounted on the vessel and rated for not less than the vessel design pressure."
  },
  {
   "n": 24,
   "area": "nozzles",
   "check": "Vessel safety valves",
   "answer": "Safety valves with manual lifting levers on each surge vessel, sized by the manufacturer for all operating and transient conditions; bronze body, stainless spring, Teflon seat; relief setting 350 psig unless otherwise required by ASME BPVC or vessel design and not above vessel MAWP; Kunkle Series 6030 or Conbraco 19-Series or equal. A bronze globe vent valve is also required on each vessel (p. 20).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 19",
   "quote": "Relief pressure setting: 350 psig unless otherwise required by ASME BPVC or vessel design."
  },
  {
   "n": 25,
   "area": "fabrication",
   "check": "Lifting lugs",
   "answer": "Lifting lugs designed for safe handling of the fully fabricated vessel, plus lifting lugs on both the manway cover and the shell for cover removal.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "quote": "Lifting lugs: Provide lifting lugs designed for safe handling of the fully fabricated vessel."
  },
  {
   "n": 26,
   "area": "coating",
   "check": "Interior lining and exterior coating",
   "answer": "Interior factory-coated with NSF 61 high-solids epoxy per Section 09 96 01, minimum 10 to 12 mils; exterior per Section 09 96 01; excess weld reinforcement removed and internal edges ground to 1/8 in minimum radius. Section 09 96 01 itself assigns a 16-20 mil system to tank interiors and is ambiguous for a buried tank exterior (see contradictions).",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 13",
   "quote": "Minimum interior coating thickness shall be 10 to 12 mils."
  },
  {
   "n": 27,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "Pressure test",
   "answer": "Source testing per Section 46 05 94 (Addendum 2 3.03.C.2), which requires a hydrostatic test of pressure-containing parts at the code-required level above design pressure or operating pressure, whichever is higher; no test pressure number is stated. Data reports must document hydrostatic testing. The air receiver is tested to 1.3 times design working pressure.",
   "evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 1709",
   "quote": "Hydrostatically pressure test pressure containing parts at the appropriate standard or code required level above the equipment component specified design pressure"
  },
  {
   "n": 28,
   "area": "testing",
   "check": "Test witnessing",
   "answer": "Tank functional (field) testing is witnessed; compressor source test not witnessed (Level 1 General Equipment Performance Test), with Level 1 vibration and noise tests; electrical/I&C source test not witnessed, functional test witnessed. Witnessing of the vessel shop hydrotest is not stated.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 23",
   "quote": "Tank: a. Test witnessing: Witnessed."
  },
  {
   "n": 29,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Who must supply the pressure vessel; named manufacturers",
   "answer": "The pressure tank must be provided by the surge control system manufacturer, which supplies the complete system (vessel, level control, compressor, receiver, controls) under single-manufacturer responsibility. Named: Pulsco; Pressure Vessel Technologies/Wagner Plat Works West; or approved equal.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "quote": "Pressure tank shall be provided by the surge control system manufacturer and shall be one of the following or approved equal:"
  },
  {
   "n": 30,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Air receiver requirements",
   "answer": "Receiver is part of the system supply: ASME, National Board coded, tested to 1.3 times design working pressure, with pressure gauge, safety valve, automatic condensate drain trap, NPT taps and steel mounting feet; minimum capacity 80 gallons; sized by the manufacturer. Compressors reciprocating (Ingersoll-Rand, Quincy, Gardner Denver or equal), air-cooled, oil-lubricated, 460 V 3-phase TEFC motor.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 15",
   "quote": "Air receiver shall be ASME, National Board coded, and tested to 1.3 times the design working pressure."
  },
  {
   "n": 31,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Number of compressors",
   "answer": "Two compressor skids, CMP-331A (No. 1) and CMP-331B (No. 2), on the revised P&ID 30N32 (Addendum 4), served by one compressor air receiver control panel VCP-331 mounted on the air receiver. The specification does not state a compressor count.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf, p. 33 (sheet 30N32)",
   "quote": "COMPRESSOR SKID NO. 1 COMPRESSOR SKID NO. 2"
  },
  {
   "n": 32,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Bid Q&A on supply boundary of the surge P&ID",
   "answer": "Addendum 4 Q&A item 36 confirms all items on sheet 30N32 are vendor supplied; item 37 states 30N32 was reissued in Addendum 4. The revised 30N32 includes the two vessels, both compressor skids, VCP-320, VCP-331, level instruments and sump pumps PMP-321A/B and PMP-322A/B.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf, p. 7",
   "quote": "Please confirm that all items shown on Sheet 30N32 are vendor supplied. Confirmed, all items are vendor supplies"
  },
  {
   "n": 33,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Manufacturer field services and training",
   "answer": "Manufacturer's representative on site: installation 1 trip, 3-day minimum; functional testing 1 trip, 3-day minimum each; training 1 session of 2 hours maintenance and 1 session of 2 hours operation; certificates of source testing and of installation and functionality compliance.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 23",
   "quote": "Installation: 1 trip, 3-day minimum. b. Functional Testing: 1 trip, 3-day minimum each."
  },
  {
   "n": 34,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Warranty",
   "answer": "43 42 21.12 refers to Section 01 78 36 (no special vessel warranty term). General Conditions VIII: one year after Initial Acceptance, or longer where specific warranties are required.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-ifb-6-2-26.pdf, p. 76",
   "quote": "If, prior to Final Acceptance or within one (1) year after the date of Initial Acceptance, or for such longer periods"
  },
  {
   "n": 35,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Buy America / domestic content and tariff terms",
   "answer": "No Buy America, American Iron and Steel or BABA requirement was found (text layer of all nine files searched; the only 'domestic manufacture' clause is for structural fasteners in Section 05 12 00). The IFB special conditions include a tariff adjustment clause: Contractor notifies Thornton within 30 days of a tariff change after award and the price is adjusted; bids must not carry a tariff contingency.",
   "evidence": "12-777xp-ifb-6-2-26.pdf, p. 39",
   "quote": "Tariff Adjustments: If new tariffs are enacted, or existing tariffs are modified after the contract award, Contractor shall notify Thornton within thirty (30) days"
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "topic": "Design pressure (superseded value)",
   "side_a": "Original 43 42 21.08: “fabricated in accordance with the ASME BPVC for unfired pressure vessels, for a design pressure rating of 150 psig.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 1677",
   "side_b": "Addendum 2, 43 42 21.12: “Minimum design pressure shall be not less than 75 psig above the maximum transient system pressure specified in this Section.” plus not less than 1.2 times maximum operating pressure (330 psig transient, 350 psig operating). Addendum 2 governs.",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "why_it_matters": "Pricing from the main spec volume would size shell and heads for 150 psig instead of roughly 420 psig, under-pricing plate, welding and weight by a large margin.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Manway size (superseded value)",
   "side_a": "Original 43 42 21.08: “Provide 24-inch diameter inspection opening on the tank.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 1678",
   "side_b": "Addendum 2: “Provide one 42-inch diameter minimum inspection opening.” with cover gasket rated for full design pressure; 30M09 Detail 4 (ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 24) shows “42\" BLIND FLANGE”. Addendum 2 governs.",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 12",
   "why_it_matters": "A 42-inch high-pressure manway, its reinforcement and blind flange cost far more than a 24-inch opening.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Air volume basis (superseded value)",
   "side_a": "Original 43 42 21.08: “The tank shall contain 60 percent air under steady state conditions.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 1677",
   "side_b": "Addendum 2: “Required minimum air volume: 8,000 gallons within the surge vessel at operating conditions.” Addendum 2 governs.",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "why_it_matters": "The air basis drives compressor and receiver sizing and the level control design.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Maximum operating pressure higher than maximum transient pressure",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2 data table: maximum operating pressure 350 psig (“TNK-321 Raw Water 144 760 50,000 350”).",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "side_b": "Addendum 2 surge design basis: “Maximum transient system pressure: 330 psig.” The same section also sets the vessel relief valve at 350 psig (Addendum 2 p. 19).",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 8",
   "why_it_matters": "The two design-pressure rules give different floors (330 + 75 = 405 psig versus 1.2 x 350 = 420 psig), so the fabricator must confirm which operating pressure is meant before sizing plate.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Drain plug valve size",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2: “Drain: Provide 8-inch drain connection with 8-inch plug valve.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "side_b": "Sheet 30M08 (Addendum 1) key tags: “21 VAL-316 4\" PLUG VALVE 22 VAL-315 4\" PLUG VALVE”; Section R places tags 21 and 22 at the valve on each tank's 8\" D drain (placement read from rendered image).",
   "side_b_evidence": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 23 (sheet 30M08)",
   "why_it_matters": "Changes the drain valve and flange rating supplied with each vessel (8-inch versus 4-inch high-pressure plug valve).",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Level transmitter type",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2: “Level measurement shall be provided by a radar level transmitter mounted on the vessel and rated for not less than the vessel design pressure.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 13",
   "side_b": "Revised P&ID 30N32 (Addendum 4) labels LE-321-01 and LE-322-01 “ULTRASONIC LEVEL METER” (0-12 FT), while the same instrument bubbles read “PTOF” (radar).",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf, p. 33 (sheet 30N32)",
   "why_it_matters": "Instrument type sets nozzle size, rating and price of the level measurement on each vessel.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Number of surge (hydropneumatic) control panels",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2: “One dedicated CP shall control each surge control system.” (two systems, so two panels; compressor controlled by a separate CP).",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 14",
   "side_b": "Revised panel schedule 30E15 (Addendum 4) has a single circuit “VCP-320 - HYDROPNEUMATIC CONTROL PANEL”, and revised P&ID 30N32 (Addendum 4, p. 33) shows one VCP-320 “HYDROPNEUMATIC CONTROL PANEL” wired to the instruments of both tanks.",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf, p. 31 (sheet 30E15; also p. 33, sheet 30N32)",
   "why_it_matters": "One versus two PLC panels with 15-inch LOIs is a material cost difference in the system supply.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Interior lining thickness",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2: “Minimum interior coating thickness shall be 10 to 12 mils.” (applied per Section 09 96 01).",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 13",
   "side_b": "Section 09 96 01: Attachment A assigns “Interior surfaces of ferrous metal tanks.” to immersed metals, system EPX-M-3 (p. 590); EPX-M-3 detail: “System Thickness (Dry Film) Total 16 to 20 mils”, SSPC-SP5 blast.",
   "side_b_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 594 (system EPX-M-3; assignment on p. 590)",
   "why_it_matters": "16-20 mils in three coats with white-metal blast costs more in material and labour than a 10-12 mil lining on two 50,000 gal vessels.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Exterior coating system for a buried tank",
   "side_a": "09 96 01 Attachment A: EPX-M-3 covers “Metals, immersed, and buried (except for 42-inch and 54-inch steel” pipelines).",
   "side_a_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 590",
   "side_b": "Same attachment, Note 1 lists among non-immersed ferrous surfaces “Exterior of tanks and other containment vessels.” (non-immersed exterior system EPU-M-1 or EPX-M-1).",
   "side_b_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 590",
   "why_it_matters": "Addendum 2 sends the exterior coating to 09 96 01, which does not say clearly whether a buried vessel exterior gets the buried/immersion epoxy or a non-immersed exterior system.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Local building code jurisdiction",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2, 43 42 21.12: vessel system to conform to IBC and “local amendments to the Pikes Peak Regional Building Code.”",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 10",
   "side_b": "Sheet 30S17 (Addendum 1) structural design information: “LOCAL AMENDMENTS: LARIMER COUNTY, COLORADO.” (also 01 81 50, Vol 2 p. 195: “Local amendments: Larimer County, Colorado.”).",
   "side_b_evidence": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 13 (sheet 30S17)",
   "why_it_matters": "Support and anchorage design must be done to one stated code basis; the vessel section names a different jurisdiction from the rest of the contract.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Sump pumps: tags and supply responsibility",
   "side_a": "Sump pumps are specified in a separate Section 43 25 00.10 as “Tag Numbers PMP-311 AND PMP-312” (also PMP-311A/B and PMP-312B on 30M06/30M08, Addendum 1), and the surge P&ID key note sends their signals to 43_25_00.10.",
   "side_a_evidence": "twp-swps_vol2of7_ifb_specs_printready.pdf, p. 1673",
   "side_b": "Revised P&ID 30N32 (Addendum 4) shows PMP-321A/B and PMP-322A/B on the surge tank P&ID, and Q&A item 36 answers “Confirmed, all items are vendor supplies” for everything on 30N32.",
   "side_b_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no4-7-16-26.pdf, p. 7",
   "why_it_matters": "If the surge vendor must supply the four vault sump pumps, they add to the package price; the tags also differ between drawings and spec.",
   "status": "likely"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Inlet/outlet nozzle arrangement",
   "side_a": "Addendum 2: “Provide one 18-inch inside diameter inlet/outlet connection. b. Provide a 90-degree downward-facing elbow with vortex suppressor.” with 8-inch clearance from the vessel bottom.",
   "side_a_evidence": "12-777xp-addend-no2-7-2-26.pdf, p. 11",
   "side_b": "Sheet 30M08 Section S (Addendum 1) shows the 18\" RW pipe entering each tank through a flanged connection at the bottom of the shell, with an external elbow below the tank (read from rendered image; no text states the nozzle location).",
   "side_b_evidence": "ad01-swps---drawings.pdf, p. 23 (sheet 30M08, Section S)",
   "why_it_matters": "A bottom nozzle and a side or top nozzle with an internal downward elbow and vortex suppressor are different fabrications; the bidder must confirm which one is meant.",
   "status": "likely"
  }
 ]
}