{
 "id": "us-elyria-oh-overbrook-packaged-liftstation-procurement",
 "country": "United States",
 "language": "English",
 "buyer": "City of Elyria, Ohio, Department of Public Service, Engineering Division (engineer: AECOM)",
 "project": "Overbrook Pump Station II Procurement: supply of a factory-built packaged wastewater lift station with back-up power",
 "year": "2024",
 "files": [
  {
   "file": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf",
   "pages": 272,
   "text_layer": true,
   "what_it_is": "Complete bid package: invitation, instructions, agreement, bid form (pp. 29-31), forms, supplementary and EJCDC general conditions, Ohio WPCLF federal provisions incl. BABA/AIS (pp. 112-218), specs 01 33 00-P, 33 32 16-P (pp. 229-244) and 43 21 16-P (pp. 245-256), and 15 plan sheets (pp. 258-272, vector; E1 on p. 270 has no text layer for its labels)"
  }
 ],
 "quality": "One long PDF where 85% is boilerplate; the equipment facts sit in 28 spec pages that disagree with each other, with the bid form and with the electrical sheet, and E1 labels can only be read visually.",
 "read_by": "Mavlon, read from the documents with AI help before any run, November 2026",
 "items": [
  "One factory-built underground duplex sewage pump station (Excel Fluid Group): 6 ft x 16.5 ft HDPE wet well, polymer concrete flattop, aluminum NoVault enclosure with crane",
  "Two Barnes SITHE 7.5 HP explosion-proof submersible chopper pumps with guide rails and break-away fittings",
  "Duplex ARC-Sentry control panel with two constant-torque VFDs (single-phase in), VEGA radar level, Time Mark controller, back-up floats",
  "4-inch discharge piping with plug and check valves and a Siemens 4-inch magmeter",
  "Natural gas standby generator with automatic transfer switch",
  "Factory tests, 5 person-days of field service, start-up and training"
 ],
 "checks": [
  {
   "n": 1,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "What does the City buy under this procurement?",
   "answer": "One complete factory-built, underground duplex sewage pump station with two submersible chopper non-clog pumps, controls, pump rail system and appurtenances; the contract also includes back-up power (p. 4). Installation is by the City's contractor.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 229",
   "quote": "Furnish a complete factory-built, underground sewage pump station with submersible chopper non-clog pumps"
  },
  {
   "n": 2,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "Who is named as the pump station fabricator?",
   "answer": "Excel Fluid Group LLC (\"EXCEL\" or \"EFG\"). Plan sheet PS1 (p. 269) is an Excel Fluid Group drawing (Q19262) provided for inclusion in the bid documents.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 234",
   "quote": "Pump Station Fabricator: Excel Fluid Group LLC"
  },
  {
   "n": 3,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "Which pumps are specified, and how many?",
   "answer": "Two Barnes SITHE explosion-proof, oil-filled submersible chopper pumps. The model is written three different ways: 4XSCDGN (p. 235), 4XSCDG75N4-230 (p. 248) and 4XSCDF75 (drawing PS1, p. 269).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 235",
   "quote": "Two (2) Barnes SITHE Model No. 4XSCDGN Explosion Proof Oil Filled"
  },
  {
   "n": 4,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What is the primary duty point of each pump?",
   "answer": "283 US gpm. The head is ambiguous: 48 ft TDH in Section 43 21 16-P (p. 249) but 46 ft TDH in Section 33 32 16-P (pp. 234 and 235).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 249",
   "quote": "Primary Flow 283 US GPM Primary Head 48 TDH - Feet"
  },
  {
   "n": 5,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What secondary duty point and minimum efficiency are required?",
   "answer": "Secondary point 370 US gpm at 42 ft TDH. Minimum hydraulic efficiency 52% (same table).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 249",
   "quote": "Secondary Flow 370 US GPM Secondary Head 42 TDH - Feet"
  },
  {
   "n": 6,
   "area": "electrical",
   "check": "What are the pump motor ratings?",
   "answer": "7.5 HP, 230 V, 3 phase, 60 Hz, 1750 rpm, service factor 1.2, 4-inch discharge. Page 252 adds: NEMA Design B squirrel-cage, dielectric-oil-filled, Class H insulation, inverter duty to NEMA MG-1 Part 31, 15 starts per hour.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 249",
   "quote": "Motor Speed 1750 RPM Motor HP 7.5 HP Frequency 60 Hz Voltage 230 V Phase 3 ph"
  },
  {
   "n": 7,
   "area": "electrical",
   "check": "What hazardous-area rating must the pump motor carry?",
   "answer": "CSA listed to the CSA harmonized standard, Class I Division 1 Group C&D explosion-proof, T4 temperature rating.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 252",
   "quote": "Class I Division 1 Group C&D Explosion-Proof with a T4 temperature rating"
  },
  {
   "n": 8,
   "area": "materials",
   "check": "What are the main pump materials?",
   "answer": "Impeller standard ASTM A536 65-45-12 ductile iron (ASTM A532 Class III Type A white iron is listed as 'Optional', with no price line for it). Volute ASTM A48 Class 30 cast iron; slicing blade and striker plate ASTM A276 440C stainless, heat treated to 53-60 HRC. Page 250 adds 416 SS shaft and two coats of Axalta Corlar epoxy, 10 mil minimum.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 249",
   "quote": "Impeller Standard: ASTM A536, 65-45-12 Ductile Iron"
  },
  {
   "n": 9,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What wet well is included?",
   "answer": "One 6-ft diameter, 16.5-ft deep monolithic structural HDPE wet well with inlet hub and anti-flotation flange; Castinite polymer concrete flattop (18,000 psi, minimum 84 x 84 in opening, 6 x 36 in cable tray); aluminum 300 psf lockable dual hatch with safety grate.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 234",
   "quote": "One 6-foot diameter, 16.5 ft deep monolithic structural HDPE"
  },
  {
   "n": 10,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What above-ground enclosure is specified?",
   "answer": "Aluminum NoVault enclosure, EXCEL Model EX-ALNV2, with sandstone exterior covering, insulation, rubber lining, gull-wing doors, LED lighting, ventilation fan with electric heater and a stowaway crane (page 237: 120 VAC electric winch rated for 800 lb).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 235",
   "quote": "Manufacturer / Model #: EXCEL Model # EX-ALNV2."
  },
  {
   "n": 11,
   "area": "controls",
   "check": "What control panel is specified?",
   "answer": "EXCEL Fluid Group 'ARC-Sentry' duplex control panel customized for the City of Elyria, with arc-flash shielding and auxiliary 6A dry contacts for the City's radio signals (level, flow, alarms, run, overtemp, seal fail, drive fault, ATS, generator). Page 238: NEMA 12 steel enclosure, UL listed.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 237",
   "quote": "Duplex Control Panel customized for City of Elyria"
  },
  {
   "n": 12,
   "area": "electrical",
   "check": "What VFDs are required, and is an alternate price asked for?",
   "answer": "Constant-torque VFDs sized for 230 VAC 60 Hz single-phase input and three-phase output (they also do the phase conversion). Allen-Bradley is the base bid. A deduct price is requested for Schneider ATV 320.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 239",
   "quote": "Alternative VFD supplier consideration. Provide deduct for Schneider ATV 320."
  },
  {
   "n": 13,
   "area": "controls",
   "check": "What level sensing and pump controller are specified?",
   "answer": "Wired radar level sensor VEGA VEGAPULS C21 (PVDF, two-wire 4-20 mA, FM Class 1 Div 1) and the City-standard TIME MARK Model 4052 pump-down controller. Back-up floats: EFG #4000020 or Flygt ENM-10 (pp. 239-240).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 239",
   "quote": "Manufacturer/Model: VEGA VEGAPULS C21."
  },
  {
   "n": 14,
   "area": "excluded",
   "check": "Who furnishes the telemetry radio?",
   "answer": "The City of Elyria furnishes and programs the radio (ELPRO 905U transmitter/receiver with ELPRO 115S I/O expansion); EFG installs it in the control panel.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 240",
   "quote": "Components furnished/programmed by City of Elyria for EFG to install in Control Panel."
  },
  {
   "n": 15,
   "area": "controls",
   "check": "What flow meter is specified?",
   "answer": "Siemens Sitrans 4-inch magnetic flowmeter: Teflon liner, 316L electrodes and grounding rings, 304 SS ANSI 150 flanges, remote field-mount 4-20 mA transmitter.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 242",
   "quote": "Manufacturer/ Model: SIEMENS Sitrans located per system drawing layout."
  },
  {
   "n": 16,
   "area": "design",
   "check": "What valve makes are named?",
   "answer": "Plug valves: Milliken Ballcentric, with operating wrench. Check valves: GA Industries Figure 340D lever-and-weight swing check (cast iron body, stainless shafts, bronze sleeves).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 242",
   "quote": "GA Industries GA-Figure 340D Lever & Weight Swing Check."
  },
  {
   "n": 17,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "What quantities does the plan bill of materials show?",
   "answer": "Drawing PS1 (Excel Q19262) BOM: HDPE basin 6 ft x 16.5 ft (1), 4-in check valve (2), 4-in plug valve (3), 4-in bypass with cam lock (1), 4-in flowmeter (1), air release valve (1), Barnes pump 4XSCDF75 (2), 4x4 BAF (2), 4-float bracket assembly (1), transducer with stilling tube (1). The specifications give no valve quantities.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 269",
   "quote": "4\" PLUG VALVE 3"
  },
  {
   "n": 18,
   "area": "electrical",
   "check": "What standby power does the specification call for?",
   "answer": "A natural gas generator, Kohler base bid (Generac also listed), 230 V single phase, sized by the supplier for the station load (no kW is given), with sheet-metal enclosure, block heater and battery charger, plus an automatic transfer switch with dry contacts. Plan sheet E1 shows a portable generator and manual transfer switch instead (see contradictions).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 243",
   "quote": "230V, single phase, sized for power requirement of station."
  },
  {
   "n": 19,
   "area": "electrical",
   "check": "What pump power cable length is required?",
   "answer": "Not fixed. The specification gives a menu, (30/50/75/100) ft, of CSA submersible Type W cable with sensor leads in one jacket, and no length is selected anywhere in the text layer.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 253",
   "quote": "Pump shall be equipped with (30/50/75/100) ft of a CSA qualified submersible power cable"
  },
  {
   "n": 20,
   "area": "scope",
   "check": "What spare parts must be supplied?",
   "answer": "Spare parts are in the pump maker's scope (43 21 16-P, 1.01 D.11), but no list or quantity is given anywhere. Section 33 32 16-P points to 'Section 43 32 16-P', which does not exist; the pump section is 43 21 16-P. Full text layer searched for 'spare' (hits only on pp. 164, 180, 231, 245, 248).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 231",
   "quote": "Spare Parts – See Submersible Chopper Pump SPECIFICATION SECTION 43 32"
  },
  {
   "n": 21,
   "area": "services",
   "check": "What factory tests are required on the pumps?",
   "answer": "Certified pump performance test to Hydraulic Institute 11.6 and 14.6, plus a check of motor voltage and frequency, a motor and cable insulation test to CSA criteria, and a dielectric test on each motor.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 255",
   "quote": "Certified testing is required in accordance with Hydraulic Institute Standards 11.6 and 14.6."
  },
  {
   "n": 22,
   "area": "services",
   "check": "How much field service is required?",
   "answer": "A factory-trained service technician (at least 5 years' experience) on site for installation inspection (2 person-days), functional completion testing (1), field performance testing (1) and vendor training (1): 5 person-days, excluding travel. Unused days are credited at the published field service rate; any extra time needed to place the equipment in operation is at no cost to the Owner.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 232",
   "quote": "Field Performance Testing: Field performance test equipment specified. a. 1 person-days"
  },
  {
   "n": 23,
   "area": "services",
   "check": "What field running test criteria apply?",
   "answer": "Running test of each pump in the City's presence: vibration limit 50% of ANSI/HI allowable; page 244 adds bearing temperature not above 180 F, not less than 4 hours of continuous operation at each condition, repeat until passed, and the Contractor furnishes water, gauges and flow meters.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 243",
   "quote": "Limit: 50 percent of ANSI/HI allowable limits."
  },
  {
   "n": 24,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "What warranty applies to the pumps?",
   "answer": "Ambiguous. Section 43 21 16-P requires a full 5-year pump warranty starting at the date of shipment, while the Instructions to Bidders set a 1-year warranty (equipment and labor) from Substantial Completion (p. 14).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 248",
   "quote": "Pumps shall come with a full 5-Year warranty, that begins at date of shipment from manufacturer’s facility."
  },
  {
   "n": 25,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Which domestic-content rules apply?",
   "answer": "Build America, Buy America (BABA) and American Iron and Steel (p. 167) acknowledgements must be signed (Ohio WPCLF/SRF funding). Pumps must also be assembled and tested in the USA (p. 248), and Buy Ohio applies 'to the extent practicable' (p. 4).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 142",
   "quote": "requires all of the iron and steel, manufactured products, and construction materials used in the project to be produced in the United States"
  },
  {
   "n": 26,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "What liquidated damages apply, and from what date?",
   "answer": "$500 per calendar day after the completion time in Article 3, which is September 30, 2024, plus the cost of any extra inspection caused by the delay.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 17",
   "quote": "the sum of five hundred dollars ($500.00) for each calendar day that expires after the time specified in Article 3"
  },
  {
   "n": 27,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "How is the price submitted?",
   "answer": "One lump sum price, in numbers and in words, on a bid form headed 'LUMP SUM CONTRACT'. There are no line items, alternates or deduct lines (the invitation calls it a unit price contract; see contradictions).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 30",
   "quote": "Bidder will complete the Work in accordance with the Contract Documents, for the lump sum price"
  },
  {
   "n": 28,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "Are sales taxes included in the price?",
   "answer": "No. The City is exempt from Ohio sales and use taxes on materials and equipment, and they must not be included in the bid price.",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 13",
   "quote": "The City is exempt from Ohio State sales and use taxes on the materials and equipment to be incorporated into the work."
  },
  {
   "n": 29,
   "area": "commercial",
   "check": "What are the payment and retainage terms?",
   "answer": "Monthly progress payments at 90% of work completed and of equipment delivered to site (10% retainage); retainage may drop to 5% thirty days after substantial completion and is released after the punch list (pp. 13-14). A bid guaranty (bond, or 10% check or letter of credit) and full-amount performance and payment bonds are required (p. 10).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 17",
   "quote": "progress payments will be in an amount equal to ninety percent (90%) of the Work completed"
  },
  {
   "n": 30,
   "area": "excluded",
   "check": "What work is outside the supplier's scope?",
   "answer": "Work by others (the City's contractor): offload and install the HDPE wet well; install pumps, removal systems and wet-well piping; set the flattop and enclosure; conduit and wiring from utility pole to power pedestal; invert pipe and force main connection (pp. 232-233); unloading, storage and installation (p. 246); Type 316 SS anchor bolts (p. 254).",
   "evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 232",
   "quote": "Offload and Install HDPE Wet Well"
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "topic": "Pump rated head",
   "side_a": "Section 33 32 16-P: 283 gpm at 46 ft TDH (repeated on p. 235 as the performance rating point). Quote: \"Operate each pump and motor to provide 283 gpm output capacity at 46 ft TDH\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 234",
   "side_b": "Section 43 21 16-P: 283 gpm at 48 ft TDH. Quote: \"Primary Flow 283 US GPM Primary Head 48 TDH - Feet\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 249",
   "why_it_matters": "The pump is selected and guaranteed at the rated point; a 2 ft head difference can change the impeller trim, the curve guarantee and the field test pass/fail.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Pump model number (spec vs spec)",
   "side_a": "Section 33 32 16-P names model 4XSCDGN. Quote: \"Barnes SITHE Model No. 4XSCDGN\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 235",
   "side_b": "Section 43 21 16-P names model 4XSCDG75N4-230. Quote: \"Pumps shall be Barnes Oil Filled SITHE Chopper model 4XSCDG75N4-230.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 248",
   "why_it_matters": "The supplier must price one exact model; one string carries no horsepower or voltage code.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Pump model number (spec vs drawing)",
   "side_a": "Section 43 21 16-P names model 4XSCDG75N4-230. Quote: \"Barnes Oil Filled SITHE Chopper model 4XSCDG75N4-230\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 248",
   "side_b": "Drawing PS1 bill of materials names 4XSCDF75. Quote: \"BARNES PUMP, 4XSCDF75\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 269",
   "why_it_matters": "The 'F' versus 'G' in the model string may be a different pump; the quoted model must match what is drawn and specified.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Standby generator and transfer switch",
   "side_a": "Specification 2.09: natural gas generator (Kohler base bid) with an automatic transfer switch. Drawing PS1 (p. 269) agrees: 'NATURAL GAS GENERATOR', 'MILBANK W/ATS'. Quote: \"Natural Gas Generator 1. Manufacturer: a. Kohler (BASE BID)\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 243",
   "side_b": "Plan sheet E1 one-line diagram: portable generator with Cam-Lok connectors and a combination service disconnect with interlocked-breaker manual transfer switch. Quote: \"PORTABLE GENERATOR AND CAM-LOK CONNECTORS\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 270 (quote read from image)",
   "why_it_matters": "A permanent natural gas genset with ATS is a large cost item; a portable-generator connection with a manual transfer switch is a small one.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Warranty",
   "side_a": "Instructions to Bidders: 1 year, equipment and labor, from Substantial Completion. Quote: \"The duration of the Bidders warranty, including equipment and labor, shall be one (1) year from the date of Substantial Completion\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 14",
   "side_b": "Section 43 21 16-P: full 5-year pump warranty from date of shipment. Quote: \"Pumps shall come with a full 5-Year warranty, that begins at date of shipment from manufacturer’s facility.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 248",
   "why_it_matters": "A 5-year full warranty from shipment costs much more to carry than 1 year from substantial completion.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Contract time",
   "side_a": "Invitation to Bid: 112 days from Notice to Commence; all work by September 30, 2024. Quote: \"The contractor will have 112 days from the date of the Notice to Commence Work to complete the Work.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 4",
   "side_b": "Bid Form: substantial completion within 365 days of Notice to Commence; all work by September 30, 2024. Quote: \"substantially completed within 365 days from the date of the Notice to Commence Work\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 29",
   "why_it_matters": "With liquidated damages at $500 per day, the governing date sets the delivery promise the supplier can make.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Contract type",
   "side_a": "Invitation to Bid calls it a unit price contract (Instructions 12.3, p. 11, also describe unit prices times quantities). Quote: \"Sealed bids for a unit price contract\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 4",
   "side_b": "The Bid Form is headed lump sum contract and has one lump sum price. Quote: \"BID FORM LUMP SUM CONTRACT\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 29",
   "why_it_matters": "Decides whether the bid is broken into unit prices and how quantity changes are paid.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "VFD deduct with no place on the bid form",
   "side_a": "Specification asks for a deduct price for Schneider ATV 320 drives. Quote: \"Provide deduct for Schneider ATV 320.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 239",
   "side_b": "The Bid Form has a single lump sum price and no alternate or deduct line; the Invitation (p. 4) says no bidder may take exception. Quote: \"for the lump sum price of: LUMP SUM PRICE\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 30",
   "why_it_matters": "The requested deduct cannot be entered on the prescribed form, so the drive choice and its price stay open.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Section cross-reference",
   "side_a": "Section 33 32 16-P sends pump capacities, operating data and spare parts to Section 43 32 16-P (also p. 231). Quote: \"Pump capacities and operating data are indicated in Section 43 32 16-P.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 234",
   "side_b": "The pump section in the package is numbered 43 21 16-P; no 43 32 16-P exists. Quote: \"SECTION 43 21 16-P\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 245",
   "why_it_matters": "Spare parts are referred to a section that does not exist, so the spare parts list is undefined.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Mechanical seal faces",
   "side_a": "Section 43 21 16-P material table: SiC/SiC upper seal, then tungsten carbide for both upper and lower seals. Quote: \"Silicon Carbide/Silicon Carbide/Buna Upper Seal, Tungsten Carbide/Tungsten Carbide/Buna for both Upper and Lower Seals\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 250",
   "side_b": "Same section, text: lower seal silicon carbide on silicon carbide (Section 33 32 16-P, p. 236, also says SiC both seals). Quote: \"Lower seal shall have a silicon carbide rotating face and a silicon carbide stationary face\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 251",
   "why_it_matters": "Seal face material changes seal cost and the pump configuration the maker must quote.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Impeller pump-out vanes",
   "side_a": "Section 33 32 16-P: pump-out vanes on the back side. Quote: \"Impeller: enclosed dual-vane, with pump out vanes on back side.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 236",
   "side_b": "Section 43 21 16-P: pump-out vanes on both sides. Quote: \"Dual-vane design with pump out vanes on both sides.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 250",
   "why_it_matters": "Different impeller patterns; the standard catalog impeller may meet only one of them.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Field test duration and test water",
   "side_a": "Section 33 32 16-P: at least four hours of continuous operation at each condition; wastewater, or water if not available. Quote: \"Test Duration: Not less than four hours of continuous operation at each condition specified and indicated.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 244",
   "side_b": "Section 43 21 16-P: field test with potable water for a minimum of 30 minutes. Quote: \"field tested using potable water for a minimum of 30 minutes\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 256",
   "why_it_matters": "Sets the technician time on site and the test water arrangements the supplier must allow for.",
   "status": "confirmed"
  },
  {
   "topic": "Labor in an equipment-only contract",
   "side_a": "Invitation to Bid: the contract is for equipment and includes no labor charges (yet labor must meet prevailing wage). Quote: \"This contract is for the purchase of equipment and does not included any labor charges.\"",
   "side_a_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 4",
   "side_b": "Section 33 32 16-P requires a service technician on site for installation, testing and training person-days. Quote: \"Service Technician must be present on site for all items listed below.\"",
   "side_b_evidence": "Elyria_Overbrook_PS_II_Procurement_Bid_Package.pdf, p. 232",
   "why_it_matters": "Field service days are paid labor; whether they are priced, and at what wage rate, is unclear.",
   "status": "likely"
  }
 ]
}